Sales services
Immediate sale
Auctions vs Direct Negotiations
Are you facing the decision of selling your property and wondering whether an auction or direct negotiations is the better way to go? This decision can impact your sales proceeds by up to 15%. We explore both methods so you can make the most profitable choice.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
Auctions are quick and potentially lucrative when demand is high, but they are legally binding.
Direct negotiations offer maximum control and flexibility, but they can take longer.
The bidding process is a flexible alternative where the seller is not obliged to sell, and often higher prices are achieved.
The sale of a property is a significant financial transaction. Choosing the right sales strategy – auctions vs. direct negotiations – is a critical success factor. Many owners underestimate how much this decision can impact the timeline and the final price achieved. This article analyzes both approaches, highlights their respective advantages and disadvantages, and provides you with a solid foundation to choose the optimal strategy for your situation and avoid pitfalls. Careful consideration can make the difference between a good and an excellent sales outcome.
Before we delve deeper into the comparison between auctions vs. direct negotiations, a clear distinction of terms is crucial. A genuine real estate auction, conducted by sworn auctioneers, is legally binding; the acceptance of a bid necessarily results in a sale. The more common bidding process in Germany, however, is not binding for the seller – the highest bid does not have to be accepted. Direct negotiations, often supported by estate agents, involve individual discussions and price negotiations with potential buyers. These distinctions are essential for the strategic orientation of your sale. Understanding these mechanisms forms the basis for the following analysis of the respective advantages.
Property auctions fully realise their potential particularly with high demand and for unique properties. Due to the competition among bidders, selling prices can often be achieved that are up to 20% above the original estimated value. A clear advantage is the speed: An auction can shorten the entire sales process to just a few weeks. Additionally, the process is transparent, and the contract is legally binding, excluding any renegotiations. For sellers aiming for a fast and potentially very profitable sale, this can be the optimal solution. However, a professional property valuation in advance is essential. The next consideration concerns the flexibility and control in the sales process.
Direct negotiations offer sellers the highest level of control and flexibility. They can choose the buyer themselves and negotiate individual contract terms. Studies show that, with broker support in direct sales, sale prices can be achieved that are 10-15% higher than private sales, thanks to professional price negotiation. This approach is particularly suitable if there are specific buyer preferences or if the timing of the sale is less critical. The ability to cater to individual needs is a key advantage. You retain full decision-making power until the notary appointment. But which method is right for your specific situation?
Every sales strategy carries specific risks. In auctions, there is a risk that the desired price may not be reached, even with a minimum bid, if the demand is lower than expected. In direct negotiations, the process can become prolonged, with the risk that buyers may withdraw just before completion. The commission for brokers in direct negotiations usually ranges from 3% to 7% of the sale price. Carefully considering these factors is crucial. Here are some points to consider:
Auction: Risk of not achieving the desired price with a low number of bidders.
Auction: Less control over the group of potential buyers.
Direct negotiation: Potential for lengthy negotiations that can last over 3 months.
Direct negotiation: Risk of prospective buyers withdrawing even after a verbal agreement.
A neutral evaluation by Auctoa or a conversation with our ImmoGPT can help you better assess these risks for your property and minimise risks. Choosing the right strategy depends greatly on your individual goals.
The bidding process represents an interesting hybrid form and is often mistakenly equated with an auction. The crucial difference: As a seller, you are not obliged to accept the highest bid in the bidding process. You can use the bids as market feedback and then decide whether to sell, to whom, or whether to enter further negotiations with the highest bidder. ImmoHanse24 reports price increases of 25,000 EUR to 50,000 EUR through bidding processes. This method offers high flexibility and, if conducted correctly, can optimise the selling price without precluding the final sales decision. The non-binding nature for the seller is the greatest advantage of the bidding process. It combines competitive elements of an auction with the control of direct negotiations. Next, we'll look at how to make the optimal decision for your property.
The choice between auctions vs. direct negotiations (or a bidding process) depends on several factors. For urgently needed liquidity and in cases of high demand, an auction can be ideal and reduce the sales process to less than 2 months. If you value maximum control, buyer selection, and individual arrangements, direct negotiations are often more suitable, even if the process may take 3-6 months. Consider the following aspects for your decision:
Time horizon: How quickly must the sale occur? Auctions are usually faster.
Type and location of property: Is it a standard property or a unique property in a prime location? The latter often benefits from auctions.
Risk appetite: How important is a guaranteed minimum price to you versus the chance of achieving a high price?
Need for control: Do you want to actively shape the choice of buyer and contract details?
Market conditions: Is demand currently high or low in your region? High demand favours competitive processes.
A data-driven assessment from Auctoa can provide you with precise insights into which strategy promises the greatest success for your specific property and how to ensure transparency in the sales process. This brings us to the conclusion.
The comparison of auctions vs. direct negotiations shows: There is no one universally best method. The key to success lies in a careful analysis of your property, personal goals, and the current market situation. An auction can lead to a sale in just 6-8 weeks and potentially bring high returns, but it also carries risks. Direct negotiations offer more control, but can be more time-consuming, often taking over 3 months. The bidding process presents a flexible alternative that generates competition without forcing you to sell. Use tools such as Auctoa's AI-supported evaluation or chat with our ImmoGPT to make an informed, data-driven decision. A strategically wise choice of sales method can increase your proceeds by over 10%. This is how you maximise your sales success.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) offers tables on house and land prices.
The Bundesbank provides an indicator system for the residential property market.
The Bundesinstitut für Bau-, Stadt- und Raumforschung (BBSR) offers a dashboard for the property market report.
The Verband deutscher Pfandbriefbanken (VDP) provides the VDP Property Price Index.
The Verband deutscher Pfandbriefbanken (VDP) provides information on the financing of residential properties.
The ifo Institut publishes press releases on global property price expectations.
The Bundesministerium der Justiz provides the Property Valuation Regulation (ImmoWertV 2022).
Is an auction always better for achieving a high price?
Not necessarily. Auctions can achieve top prices with high demand and for special items. However, in cases of low demand or for standard properties, direct negotiation with a good strategy and support from an agent can also deliver very good results or even be better.
What documents do I need for a bidding process?
For a bidding process, you essentially need the same documents as for a normal sale: a compelling property brochure, floor plans, energy certificate, land register excerpt, and other object-specific documents. An agent can assist in compiling these.
Can I, as a seller, also sell to a bidder who has not made the highest offer in a bidding process?
Yes, since the bidding process is not binding for the seller, you can accept a lower offer if, for example, you find the buyer's concept more appealing or other conditions are more advantageous.
How does Auctoa help me decide between auction and direct negotiation?
Auctoa offers AI-powered real estate valuations and analyses. These data-driven insights help you accurately assess the current market value of your property and understand the potential outcomes of different sales strategies. Our ImmoGPT can also answer your specific questions and support you in decision-making.
What role does transparency play in the various procedures?
Genuine real estate auctions offer high transparency as the bidding process is open and the award is made publicly. In bidding processes, transparency can vary depending on how the seller or agent designs it. Direct negotiations are naturally less transparent for other interested parties, as they are conducted individually.
What happens if the reserve price is not reached at an auction?
If the set reserve price is not reached at a real estate auction, no sale occurs. The owner can then offer the property again at a later date or choose another sales strategy.
