Consultation
Law
Obtain an expert opinion
An expert report can be crucial in many situations, whether for real estate appraisals, legal disputes, or clarifying matters. To ensure you receive the right report, it's important to understand the legal basis and procedure. Do you need assistance in choosing the right expert? Contact us now!
An evaluation report from Auctoa provides the highest assessment accuracy by using cutting-edge AI and real-time market data integration.
Auctoa significantly reduces the time taken to create reports and minimises risks in property decisions, leading to more efficient and well-informed decision-making.
By combining digital innovation and human expertise, Auctoa guarantees an accurate and market-appropriate valuation that reflects the true property value and reduces incorrect decisions.
Obtaining an expert opinion can be crucial in many situations, whether in a legal context or for private decisions. This article provides you with a comprehensive overview of the various types of expert reports, from court reports to private reports, and shows you how to select the right expert and keep an eye on costs. We highlight the importance of expert opinions for your decision-making and equip you with the necessary knowledge to make informed decisions.
Whether it is about valuing a property, clarifying a medical issue, or assessing technical systems, a qualified report provides clarity and serves as a solid foundation for your next steps. The significance of expert opinions lies in their objectivity and independence, ensuring a fair and transparent evaluation.
Our goal is to provide you with comprehensive information on the topic of "obtaining an expert opinion" so that you can navigate the complex world of expert reports and make the best possible decision. Learn more about the quality characteristics of expert opinions to ensure that you receive a well-founded and reliable result.
The legal basis is the foundation of every expert opinion. It is crucial to identify the correct legal basis, for example, § 109 SGB X, § 402 ZPO, or § 73 StPO. These norms define the requirements and scope of the expert opinion. Different legal areas entail different procedural rules and standards of evidence that must be considered when preparing an expert opinion. The legal foundation is thus the starting point for a successful and legally sound evaluation.
The validity of an expert opinion is heavily dependent on the specific legal case and the individual circumstances. Changes in the situation or the condition of the person concerned can affect the significance of an expert opinion. Therefore, it is important that the expert opinion is up-to-date at the time of the decision and takes all relevant aspects into account.
An expert opinion should always be up-to-date to ensure its validity. The independence of the expert opinion is another important factor influencing its legal acceptance.
The objectivity and independence of the assessor are of central importance. An assessor must be free from any conflicts of interest and apply their expertise impartially. Potential conflicts of interest must be disclosed to ensure the credibility of the assessment is not compromised. Choosing a qualified and specialised expert is therefore essential.
When reviewing the qualifications of the expert, you should consider the following aspects: certification and recognition, evidence of expertise and skills, as well as local market knowledge, particularly in property appraisals. An experienced expert has the necessary know-how and competence to provide a well-founded and objective evaluation.
Requirements for Expert Evidence
Certification and recognition: The expert should hold recognised certifications confirming their qualification.
Evidence of expertise and skills: The expert should demonstrate their expertise and skills through appropriate training and professional experience.
Local market knowledge (for property appraisals): For property appraisals, local market knowledge is crucial to making a realistic assessment.
The court-proof qualification of an expert is crucial to ensure that the appraisal withstands scrutiny in court.
A detailed documentation of examination methods, results, and diagnoses is essential for a comprehensible report. The assessor must justify their conclusions in a clear and logical manner so that even a non-expert can understand the evaluation. The responsibilities of the involved parties (assessor, client, examined person) must be clearly defined to ensure a smooth report process.
The assessor has the duty to provide an objective and accurate evaluation, conduct the examination carefully, and write the report in an understandable manner. The client is responsible for the appropriate selection of the assessor, clear definition of the assignment, and provision of all relevant information. The examined person must cooperate in the examination, provide truthful information, and consent to necessary investigations.
Duties of the Assessor
Objective and accurate evaluation: The assessor must base their evaluation on objective criteria and sound expertise.
Careful conduct of the examination: The assessor must conduct the examination carefully and conscientiously to consider all relevant aspects.
Comprehensible and transparent report creation: The assessor must write the report in a way that is understandable and transparent for non-experts.
Duties of the Client
Appropriate selection of the assessor: The client must select an assessor who has the necessary qualification and expertise.
Clear definition of the assignment: The client must define the assignment clearly and precisely so that the assessor knows which questions to answer.
Provision of all relevant information: The client must provide the assessor with all relevant information required for creating the report.
Duties of the Examined Person
Cooperation in the examination: The examined person must cooperate in the examination and provide the assessor with all necessary information.
Truthful information: The examined person must provide truthful information to enable an accurate evaluation.
Consent to necessary investigations: The examined person must consent to necessary investigations to enable a comprehensive assessment.
The creation of a report requires a structured approach and adherence to certain standards to ensure the quality and reliability of the result.
There are various types of assessments that differ in their legal significance and areas of application. Private assessments are commissioned by individuals or companies, primarily for information and decision-making purposes. Official assessments are produced by authorities and are used in decision-making as part of administrative procedures. Expert reports are commissioned by courts and serve as evidence in court proceedings.
The legal binding nature of these types of assessments varies. Expert reports typically have the highest legal binding status, as they are commissioned by a court and serve as evidence. Private assessments do not have direct legal binding force but can serve as evidence in legal proceedings. Official assessments have legal binding status within the administrative procedure in which they were created.
The different types of assessments have various applications and legal consequences that must be considered when selecting the appropriate assessment.
As a patient or affected individual, you have certain rights during the expert opinion process. You have the right to a correct and objective assessment, the right to comment and appeal, and the right to access the expert opinion. These rights aim to ensure that you are treated fairly and have the opportunity to defend yourself against incorrect or incomplete expert opinions.
If you disagree with an expert opinion, you have various options for contestation. For example, you can have a counter-expertise created or challenge the opinion in court. The expert is liable for faulty opinions according to Sections 839a, 839b BGB, Section 1 SchaG.
It is important to know your rights and assert them when necessary to protect yourself from unjustified disadvantages. The patient rights are an important part of the expert opinion process and should always be observed.
Reports play an important role in many areas of life. In medical liability, for example, they are crucial for proving treatment errors and asserting claims for damages. In property valuation, they are used to determine the market value of a property and to make a fair purchasing or selling decision.
The strategic importance of a report is particularly evident before a legal dispute. Obtaining a report early on can help strengthen one's position and achieve an out-of-court settlement.
The preparation of a market value report is a complex process that requires careful data collection and a thorough evaluation.
The creation of valuation reports comprises four phases: clarification of assignment, inspection, valuation, and preparation. During the data collection phase, property data, building plans, rental agreements, and market situation are analysed. The property inspection is to assess the condition of the building and its surroundings.
Various methods are employed in valuation, such as the comparative value method, the income value method, or the cost value method. The choice of method depends on the type of property and the purpose of the report. The duration of report creation is typically 10 working days after submission of all required documents.
The phases of creating a valuation report are crucial for an accurate and realistic property evaluation.
The obtaining of expert reports is an important step in making informed decisions. A qualified expert report provides clarity, offers an objective assessment, and serves as a solid foundation for your further steps. Whether in a legal context, property valuation, or other areas – an expert report can help you minimize risks and seize opportunities.
The importance of expert reports for decision-making lies in their independence and objectivity. An expert report offers a neutral perspective and takes into account all relevant aspects to enable a well-founded assessment.
The world of expert report creation and application is constantly changing. In the future, new technologies and methods will enable even more precise and efficient expert report preparation. It is worthwhile to keep an eye on developments in this area to benefit from the latest innovations. Are you looking for a way to secure your property decisions? Auctoa offers you the expertise you need. Our combination of AI-supported analysis and human expertise guarantees you an accurate and market-appropriate evaluation of your property. Contact us today to request your individual offer and take the first step towards a well-informed decision: Get in touch now!
The Deutsche Bundesbank provides statistics on real estate and construction pricing.
Destatis offers price indices for residential properties and building land.
Wikipedia provides a general overview of assessments and their various aspects.
Sozialverband Deutschland offers information on strengthening and developing patient rights in the context of assessments.
Institut der Wirtschaftsprüfer in Deutschland e.V. (IDW) provides information on the expert valuation of company values.
What is the advantage of an AI-driven property appraisal from Auctoa?
An AI-driven appraisal from Auctoa offers greater accuracy and speed compared to traditional methods as it relies on real-time market data and advanced algorithms.
Who is a property appraisal from Auctoa particularly suitable for?
Auctoa appraisals are ideal for property investors, banks, estate agents, property developers, and private owners who require a precise and market-aligned valuation.
What types of property appraisals does Auctoa offer?
Auctoa offers fully automated valuation platforms, hybrid AI-human appraisals, digital market analyses, and comprehensive valuation reports.
How long does it take for Auctoa to generate a property appraisal?
Generating an appraisal with Auctoa typically takes just a few days, which represents a significant time saving compared to traditional methods.
What valuation methods are used at Auctoa?
Auctoa uses recognised valuation methods such as the comparative method, the income method, and the cost method, supported by AI-driven analyses.
How does Auctoa ensure the objectivity and independence of its appraisals?
Auctoa combines AI-driven analyses with the expertise of experienced human appraisers to ensure an objective and unbiased valuation.
What does a property appraisal from Auctoa cost?
The cost of an appraisal from Auctoa varies depending on the type and scope of the appraisal. Contact Auctoa for a bespoke quote.
How can I commission a property appraisal from Auctoa?
You can commission an appraisal from Auctoa by contacting Auctoa and discussing your individual requirements.
