Consultation
Financing
International Valuation Standards
Are you unsure if your property valuation meets international standards? An incorrect valuation can have costly consequences. International valuation standards ensure accuracy and transparency. Do you want to make sure your valuation is legally compliant and free of any nasty surprises? Get in touch now and receive expert advice!
International Valuation Standards (IVS) are crucial for transparent and comparable property appraisals, especially in the global market. Compliance minimises risks and safeguards investments.
The choice of the right type of expert report (court report, private report, arbitration report) depends on the purpose and legal relevance. A court-proof report strengthens the legal position and can help avoid potential errors.
Technological innovations such as digitalisation and AI accelerate the creation of expert reports and enhance precision. The use of private expert reports can speed up court proceedings and reduce costs.
Overview of the Importance of Evaluations in an International Context
In the global real estate market, the significance of property evaluations based on international valuation standards cannot be underestimated. These evaluations form the foundation for informed decisions on real estate investments, financing, and legal disputes. Adhering to these standards ensures that valuations are transparent, comparable, and understandable, regardless of the country in which the property is located. The International Valuation Standards (IVS) play a central role in this regard.
The Role of the International Valuation Standards (IVS)
The IVS serve to harmonise valuation practices worldwide. They set out uniform guidelines for the preparation of evaluations that real estate experts are required to follow. This contributes to the transparency and comparability of valuations, which is particularly important for international investors. Compliance with the IVS ensures that valuations are based on a solid foundation and are not distorted by local peculiarities. This is particularly crucial as property valuation often forms the basis for important financial decisions.
Distinguishing Different Types of Evaluations
There are various types of evaluations that differ in their purpose and legal relevance. Court evaluations, for instance, are prepared in the context of legal proceedings, while private evaluations can be used to resolve disputes out of court. Arbitration evaluations offer a way to resolve conflicts without court involvement. The choice of the right type of evaluation depends on the specific situation. Regardless of the type of evaluation, the impartiality and expertise of the evaluator is of utmost importance. A qualified expert has the necessary technical knowledge and experience to provide an objective and well-founded evaluation.
Legal Requirements for Court Reports in Germany
In Germany, court reports are subject to strict legal requirements. The Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO) specifies the requirements for the preparation and submission of reports in court. These include, among other things, the documentation of the evaluation methodology and the traceability of the results. The judge plays a crucial role in evaluating reports and can request improvements or a new report if necessary. A court-compliant report must therefore meet legal requirements to withstand in court.
The Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO) and its Significance
The ZPO governs proceedings before German civil courts and contains specific provisions for the creation and use of reports. These regulations ensure the quality and objectivity of reports. The requirements for documentation and methodology are particularly high, as the report serves as evidence in court. The judge reviews the report for its consistency and traceability and can request further explanations or supplements if necessary. The ZPO also sets out the qualifications an expert must meet to be admitted as a court appraiser.
Expert Evidence and Its Relevance
Expert evidence plays a central role in the creation of court reports. An expert must have the necessary qualifications and certification to be able to produce a sound and objective report. The experience and expertise of the expert are crucial in minimizing risks and errors in the assessment. A lack of expertise can lead to the report being challenged in court. Choosing the right expert is therefore of great importance.
Qualifications and Certification of Experts
An expert must prove their qualifications through appropriate training, certifications, and professional experience. There are various certification bodies that examine and certify experts. A valid certification is a mark of the expert's competence and reliability. The importance of experience is particularly evident in complex evaluations, where a deep understanding of the real estate market and assessment methods is required. An experienced expert can identify and avoid potential risks and sources of error early on.
International Standards in Comparison
The International Valuation Standards (IVS) provide a framework for the preparation of reports, which is recognized worldwide. However, there are also differences and similarities in report preparation resulting from respective local laws and regulations. An expert operating internationally must therefore be familiar with the different requirements and adjust their report accordingly. Adapting to local laws and regulations is crucial to ensure that the report is legally recognized in the respective country.
Overview of Valuation Methods
The property valuation is based on various methods, which are applied depending on the type of property and the purpose of the valuation. The most common methods include the comparative value method, the income value method, and the cost value method. The selection of the appropriate method depends on several factors, such as the availability of comparable data, the property's income potential, and the condition of the building. A well-informed decision on the method to be applied is crucial for the accuracy of the valuation. Our valuation methodology provides you with an overview of the different approaches.
Comparative Value Method, Income Value Method, Cost Value Method
The comparative value method is based on comparing the property to be valued with similar properties that have recently been sold. This method is particularly suitable for residential properties where there is sufficient comparable data available. The income value method is primarily used for commercial properties, where generating rental income is the main focus. With the cost value method, the value of the property is determined based on the construction costs of the building and the land value. This method is often used for special properties or when comparable data is lacking. The valuation process should always be documented transparently and comprehensibly.
Documentation and Reporting
Comprehensive documentation and reporting are essential for the quality and credibility of an appraisal. The traceability and transparency of the valuation are crucial to avoid potential challenges. The appraisal should contain all relevant information, such as the description of the property, the valuation methods applied, the data used, and the results of the valuation. A comprehensive report helps ensure that the appraisal is legally relevant and stands up in court.
The Importance of Traceability and Transparency
Traceability means that a third party, such as a judge or an investor, can understand the valuation steps and the results of the appraisal. Transparency refers to the disclosure of all relevant information and assumptions underlying the valuation. By avoiding contradictions and disclosing all relevant information, trust in the appraisal is strengthened. Comprehensive reporting helps ensure that the appraisal is legally relevant and stands up in court.
Common Reasons for Challenging Reports
Reports can be challenged for various reasons. Common causes include flawed assessment methods, insufficient documentation, or the use of unsuitable data. A counter-report can be created to refute the findings of the original report. The strategic importance of a counter-report should not be underestimated, as it can form the basis for a successful challenge. By minimizing inconsistencies and transparently presenting the assessment methods, challenges can be avoided.
Flawed Assessment Methods and Insufficient Documentation
The choice of the wrong assessment method or the flawed application of a method can lead to an inaccurate evaluation. Insufficient documentation of the assessment steps and the data used makes it difficult to comprehend the report and offers grounds for challenges. A counter-report can be created in such cases to highlight the errors in the original report. The strategic importance of a counter-report is that it can form the basis for a successful challenge.
Arbitral Reports as a Preventive Measure
An arbitral report can be used as a preventive measure to avoid legal disputes in advance. By agreeing on an independent expert who makes a binding assessment in case of disagreement, conflicts can be resolved out of court. The role of the arbitrator is to provide an objective and impartial assessment that is acceptable to both parties. An arbitral report offers a quick and cost-effective alternative to court proceedings.
Avoiding Legal Disputes Through Independent Assessment
An arbitral report offers the possibility to settle disputes over the value of a property out of court. Both parties agree on an independent expert who makes a binding assessment. This assessment is binding for both parties unless it is obviously unfair. By avoiding legal disputes, the parties save time and costs. The role of the arbitrator is to provide an objective and impartial assessment that is acceptable to both parties.
Preservation of Evidence and Documentation of the Status Quo
Expert Reports play a crucial role in evidence preservation in time-critical situations, such as impending building damage or before construction begins. They serve to document the status quo and can be commissioned privately or by the court. Private reports offer the advantage of quicker preparation, while court reports possess greater probative value. Early evidence preservation can help avoid later disputes.
Expert Reports Before Construction Starts and in the Event of Damage
An expert report before construction begins documents the condition of neighbouring buildings to allocate later damage clearly. In cases of damage, such as cracks in masonry or moisture damage, the expert report serves to determine the cause and extent of the damage. The importance of early evidence preservation lies in its provision of an objective basis for the regulation of damages. Using certified experts (IHK, TÜV, DEKRA) ensures high-quality reports.
Private Reports for Out-of-Court Settlements
Private reports are often used for out-of-court settlements in disputes, such as construction defects, new and renovation projects, or within the framework of purchase advice. They serve in quality control and reveal hidden defects. A private report can help convince the other party of a contractual breach without necessitating legal proceedings. However, it's important to beware of courtesy reports and engage an independent expert.
Quality Control and Revealing Hidden Defects
In cases of construction defects, a private report can identify the cause and extent of the defect and estimate the remediation costs. For new and renovation projects, the private report monitors the construction execution and compliance with contractual agreements. In a purchase consultation, a private report can help uncover hidden defects and realistically assess the property's value. The warning against courtesy reports is critical, as these may not be objective and can disadvantage the client.
Insurance Reports
Insurance reports are used for damage assessment, cause investigation, and cost estimation in insurance cases. They serve as a basis for both insurers and policyholders in the regulation of damages. An insurance report should be prepared by an independent expert to ensure an objective evaluation. The role of insurers and policyholders is to support the expert in preparing the report and provide all relevant information.
Damage Assessment, Cause Investigation, and Cost Estimation
The damage assessment involves determining the extent of the damage and estimating the repair or reconstruction costs. The cause investigation aims to clarify how the damage occurred. The cost estimation involves calculating the expected costs for damage remediation. The role of insurers and policyholders is to support the expert in preparing the report and provide all relevant information.
Cost Factors in the Preparation of Expert Reports
The cost of preparing expert reports can vary depending on the type of report, the scope of evaluation, and the expert’s fee. In property valuation, the expert's fee is often calculated as a percentage of the property's value. For court reports, there are statutory regulations (JVEG) that determine the fee amount. With review reports, costs are usually shared between the parties. It is important to inform oneself in advance about the expected costs and, if necessary, to obtain several quotes.
Percentage of Property Value and Fee Costs
The percentage of property value that is calculated for preparing a report is usually between 0.5 and 1 percent. The fee costs for court reports are regulated in the Judicial Remuneration and Compensation Act (JVEG). The cost allocation for review reports typically follows the principle of causation; that is, the party requesting the review report bears the costs. It is advisable to inform oneself in advance about the expected costs and, if necessary, to obtain several quotes.
Time Frame for the Preparation of Expert Reports
The time frame for preparing expert reports depends on the complexity of the evaluation and the availability of the expert. Simple reports can be prepared within a few weeks, while complex evaluations can take several months. Commissioning a private report can expedite the process since there are no court deadlines to meet. Good planning and coordination with the expert can help minimize the time required.
Dependency on Complexity and Expert Availability
The complexity of the evaluation depends on the type of property, the scope of the documents to be reviewed, and the specific questions involved. Expert availability can also affect the time frame, as highly sought-after experts may have longer lead times. The acceleration of procedures through private reports is possible because there are no court deadlines to observe. Good planning and coordination with the expert can help minimize the time effort.
Strategic Importance of Choosing the Right Report
The choice of the right report is strategically important for the success of a legal dispute or negotiation. A court-standard report enhances the legal position and can help avoid potential errors. A less formal report might be sufficient to reach an out-of-court settlement. The decision for one type of report over another should therefore be carefully considered.
Court-Standard Report vs. Less Formal Report
A court-standard report must meet the ZPO requirements and be prepared by a court-appointed expert. It serves as evidence in court and has a high probative value. A less formal report can be prepared by a private expert and primarily serves for information and decision-making. The enhancement of the legal position through a court-standard report is significant, as it forms the basis for a successful argument in court. Avoiding potential errors is also important because errors in the report can lead to challenges and additional costs.
The Authority of the Judge in Expert Opinion Acceptance
The judge has the ultimate authority in the acceptance of expert opinions. He decides whether an expert opinion is admitted as evidence and whether it is relevant to the judgment. The judge can order amendments or new expert opinions if he has doubts about the accuracy or completeness of the expert opinion. Therefore, it is essential that the expert opinion meets legal standards and ensures a positive appraisal.
Ordering Amendments or New Expert Opinions
If the judge has doubts about the accuracy or completeness of the expert opinion, he can request the expert to make amendments or create a new expert opinion. This may be the case, for example, if the evaluation methods are not sufficiently documented or if the data used is not traceable. Compliance with legal standards is therefore crucial to achieve a positive appraisal by the judge.
Superior Appraisals to Clarify Doubts
A superior appraisal can be commissioned to resolve doubts about the accuracy of an expert opinion. This is particularly the case when private expert reports challenge the results of a court expert opinion. The superior appraisal is prepared by an independent expert who possesses special expertise. The importance of the expert's expertise lies in his ability to analyse complex issues and provide a well-founded evaluation.
Reviewing Private Expert Reports in Complex Cases
A superior appraisal serves the purpose of reviewing private expert reports in particularly complex cases. This is particularly the case when there are doubts about the expertise of the expert or when the expert opinion is flawed. The importance of the expert's expertise lies in his ability to analyse complex issues and provide a well-founded evaluation.
Use of Private Expert Reports to Expedite Proceedings
The use of private expert reports can help expedite court proceedings. Courts are increasingly using private expert reports as the basis for their decisions and often appoint the author of the private expert report as a technical witness or court expert. This saves time and costs, as a new expert report can be avoided. The judicial use of private expert reports as a basis for decisions is a trend that is likely to increase in the future.
Judicial Use of Private Expert Reports as a Basis
Courts are increasingly using private expert reports as a basis for their decisions because they can often be prepared more quickly and cheaply than court reports. The author of the private expert report is often appointed as a technical witness or court expert to bring his expertise into the proceedings. This saves time and costs, as a new expert report can be avoided.
Technological Innovations in Expert Report Preparation
Technological innovations, such as the digitalisation and automation of assessment processes, are fundamentally changing the preparation of expert reports. The use of artificial intelligence and big data enables a faster and more accurate valuation of properties. These technologies can help make the expert report process more efficient and improve the quality of the reports. Property valuation is becoming more transparent and understandable with these innovations.
Digitalisation and Automation of Assessment Processes
Digitalisation enables the electronic capture and processing of data, which speeds up and simplifies the expert report process. The automation of assessment processes, for example through the use of software, reduces manual effort and minimises the risk of errors. The use of artificial intelligence and big data allows the analysis of large data sets and the identification of patterns that are relevant for valuation. These technologies contribute to making the expert report process more efficient and improving the quality of the reports.
Adhering to international valuation standards is crucial to avoid costly mistakes in your property valuation and secure your investments. Whether court appraisals, private valuations, or arbitration appraisals – the right expertise and methodology are key to a precise and legally sound valuation. Take advantage of digitalisation and automation to speed up the appraisal process and improve the quality of your assessments. The International Valuation Standards are an essential factor for successful financing and legal safeguards.
Do you want to protect your real estate investments and ensure that your appraisals meet the highest international standards? Enter offers you comprehensive advice and support in selecting the right appraiser, applying the appropriate valuation methods, and complying with all relevant regulations. Contact us today to start your personalised consultation and place your property valuation on a secure footing. Register for free and instantly receive an initial assessment of your property's refurbishment needs. Get in touch now!
The Bundesministerium der Justiz provides the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO) online, which sets the legal framework for court expert reports in Germany.
What are the International Valuation Standards (IVS) and why are they important?
The International Valuation Standards (IVS) are uniform guidelines for preparing real estate appraisals worldwide. They ensure transparency, comparability, and traceability, which is particularly important for international investors.
What types of appraisals exist and when are they used?
There are various types of appraisals, including court appraisals (for legal proceedings), private appraisals (for out-of-court clarifications), and arbitration appraisals (for conflict resolution without court). The choice depends on the specific situation.
What are the legal requirements for court appraisals in Germany?
In Germany, the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO) regulates the requirements for court appraisals. These include the documentation of the valuation methodology and the traceability of results.
How can I successfully challenge an appraisal?
Appraisals can be challenged if they use faulty valuation methods, lack adequate documentation, or use inappropriate data. A counter-appraisal can be prepared to refute the findings.
What role do expert appraisals play?
Expert appraisals serve to secure evidence in time-sensitive situations, such as impending construction damages or before the start of construction. They document the status quo and can be commissioned privately or through court.
How can I achieve an out-of-court settlement through a private appraisal?
Private appraisals are often used for out-of-court settlements in disputes, such as construction defects or during a purchasing consultation. They serve as quality control and help uncover hidden defects.
How can I reduce the costs of an appraisal?
The costs depend on the type of appraisal, the scope of the valuation, and the expert's fees. It is advisable to inform yourself in advance about the expected costs and, if necessary, obtain multiple quotes.
What advantages does digitalisation offer in preparing appraisals?
Digitalisation and automation of valuation processes, as well as the use of artificial intelligence and big data, enable a faster and more precise valuation of real estate.
