Are you facing the decision of buying a property or leasing land? The long-term <strong>purchase or lease costs</strong> can vary significantly and greatly impact your financial future. This article highlights the decisive factors for your choice.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
The additional purchase costs can account for 10-15% of the property purchase price and need to be taken into account early on.
The ground rent is usually between 2.5-5% of the property's value per year and may increase over the term.
In the long run, purchasing a property can be more advantageous for building wealth than leasing despite high initial costs.
The question of whether buying or leasing is the better option occupies many prospective property owners and investors. Both models have specific cost structures and long-term financial impacts. There is no blanket answer, as the optimal decision depends on your individual situation, financial capabilities, and goals. This article provides a detailed analysis of the costs of buying versus leasing and helps you make an informed decision. We consider both the immediate expenses and the ongoing costs and potential changes in value.
Overview of Costs: What really comes up when buying property
The purchase of a property involves significant one-time costs that go beyond the mere purchase price. These so-called additional purchase costs can quickly amount to 10% to 15% of the purchase price. The main components include the property transfer tax, which varies depending on the federal state, as well as notary and land registry fees. For a property valued at 300,000 euros, up to an additional 45,000 euros in ancillary costs may be incurred. A precise calculation of these expenses is crucial for solid property financing. These initial investments are an important factor when comparing buying or renting costs. Knowing all the amounts involved ensures there are no nasty surprises.
Running costs of property ownership: More than just interest and repayment
In addition to the one-time purchasing ancillary costs, property owners regularly incur recurring costs. These include interest for building finance, which, despite historically low periods, can currently still range around 3% to 4%. Added to this are maintenance reserves, for which experts recommend at least 1 Euro per square metre per month. For a 100 m² house, this amounts to 1,200 Euros annually. The annual property tax is also a fixed item. These ongoing expenses must be considered when evaluating the costs of buying or leasing to realistically assess long-term financial burdens. A detailed valuation report for house costs can provide clarity here.
Lease and Heritable Building Right: What You Should Know About the Costs
The lease, particularly in the form of a ground lease, represents an alternative to buying property. In this case, the land is not purchased, but rented for a long period, often 50 to 99 years. For this, a so-called ground rent must be paid. This is usually about 2.5% to 5% of the property's value annually. With a property value of 100,000 euros, this can amount to 2,500 to 5,000 euros annually. An advantage is the lower initial capital requirement, as the purchase price of the land is eliminated. It is important to carefully examine the conditions in the lease agreement and its usage possibilities. The costs of buying or leasing mainly differ here in terms of the initial investment amount. Long-term planning is particularly relevant with lease models.
Increase in ground rent: An often underestimated cost factor
An important aspect of leasehold is the potential adjustment of the leasehold interest rate. Many contracts include value protection clauses that link the interest rate to overall price developments. Legally, an increase is possible every 3 years after the contract is concluded and thereafter every 3 years after the last increase. The increase must not be "unreasonable" and must not exceed general economic developments. However, for old contracts without clear clauses or with interest rates that have not been adjusted for a long time, there can be significant increases, in extreme cases by a factor of 10 or more. These potential cost increases are a key consideration in weighing up the costs of buying or leasing. A thorough examination of the risks and opportunities of leasehold properties is essential. Long-term financial planning can be affected by this.
Purchase versus Lease: A Comparative Analysis of Total Costs
The decision between buying and leasing strongly depends on the individual situation and timeframe. Buying involves high initial costs, but after repaying the loan, the monthly burden is reduced to ancillary costs and maintenance. With leasing, the initial costs are lower, but lease interest is incurred over the entire term. For example, a property costing €391,000 (purchase price) plus €48,000 in additional costs could result in total costs of approximately €730,000 over 27 years. A comparable rented apartment (similar to leasing) with a monthly rent of €1,231 and a 1% annual increase would reach the same total after about 41 years. In the long run, buying can be cheaper if you stay in the same place for a long time. The consideration of buying or leasing costs requires careful calculation of all factors. Specific uses, such as leasing recreational plots, require their own considerations.
Here is a comparison of the main aspects:
Buying: High initial investment, asset building, more flexibility in design, potentially lower living costs in the long term.
Leasing/Leasehold: Lower initial investment, ongoing lease interest costs, less responsibility for the property, binding to lease agreement.
Additional costs of buying: Property transfer tax (varies, e.g., 3.5% - 6.5%), notary (approx. 1.5%), land registration (approx. 0.5%), broker (often 3.57% - 7.14%).
Ongoing costs of buying: Maintenance (approx. 1-2% of the property's value p.a.), property tax (community-dependent), financing costs.
Leasing costs: Leasehold interest (often 2.5-5% of the property's value p.a.), possible adjustments, ancillary costs for the property.
These points illustrate that the decision is very individual.
Property prices in Germany: A crucial factor
The cost of land varies significantly across Germany and greatly affects the cost of purchase or lease. On average, in 2023, one square metre of land cost around €254. This represents an increase of almost 90% compared to 2013, when the price was €134/m². In major cities like Hamburg, prices can exceed €1,000/m², while in more rural areas like Thuringia, they can start at under €100/m². Munich has peak values, averaging €2,900/m². These price differences directly impact the amount of ground rent or purchase price. Those considering leasing a plot should carefully examine local standard land values. The trend in land prices is an important indicator of the economic viability of your decision.
kauf-oder-pacht-kosten
When comparing the costs of buying or leasing, the aspect of asset accumulation plays an important role. Purchased properties represent an asset that can appreciate in value. Even if renting or leasing might initially appear cheaper, the money goes to the landlord or lessor without building any personal wealth. With a moderate property value increase of only 1% per year and rising rents, a buyer's financial position may already appear better than that of a renter/lessee after about 10 years. Buying a property is therefore often a long-term investment in one's financial future. The decision whether to rent or lease land or buy it should consider this aspect. Special considerations regarding value stability apply to specific living arrangements such as tiny houses on leased land.
Conclusion: Individual analysis is the key to the right decision
What are the one-time costs when purchasing a property?
When buying a property, in addition to the purchase price, you will incur property transfer tax (depending on the federal state, 3.5% - 6.5%), notary fees (approximately 1.5%), land registry fees (approximately 0.5%), and possibly an estate agent’s commission (often between 3.57% and 7.14% including VAT).
What are the ongoing costs for a leased property/land?
The main costs are the lease or ground rent. Additional costs can include land tax (often included in the lease fee), insurance for the land, and possibly maintenance costs for the land, depending on the contract arrangement.
How long do leases for land usually last?
Ground leases often have long durations, typically between 50 and 99 years. Shorter lease contracts are common for other types of leases (e.g., agricultural leases, recreational land) and vary greatly.
Is an increase in the lease fee possible during the contract term?
Yes, adjustments to the ground rent in ground leases are common, often linked to price indices (value protection clause). Legally, adjustments are possible every 3 years, provided they are contractually agreed and not unreasonable.
What are the advantages of leasing over purchasing?
The main advantage of leasing is the lower initial capital requirement, as the high purchase price for the land is eliminated. This can facilitate access to a property, particularly in expensive areas.
What are the advantages of purchasing over leasing?
Purchasing results in ownership and enables wealth accumulation through value appreciation and repayment. Owners have complete freedom in design and are independent from a landlord. In the long term, housing costs can decrease once the loan is paid off.
Additional useful links
Statistisches Bundesamt provides data on construction prices and the property price index.
Deutsche Bundesbank offers an indicator system for the residential property market.
Statistisches Bundesamt provides tables on house and land prices.
Sparkasse provides information on additional costs when purchasing property.
Immowelt offers information about lease agreements.
Dr. Klein compares renting and buying properties.
ZIA presents a future study.
FAQ
What are the one-time costs involved in buying a property?
When purchasing real estate, in addition to the purchase price, there are land transfer taxes (depending on the state, 3.5% - 6.5%), notary fees (approx. 1.5%), land registry fees (approx. 0.5%), and possibly brokerage commissions (often between 3.57% and 7.14% including VAT).
What are the running costs for a leased property/land?
The main costs are the lease or ground rent. Additional costs may include property tax (often included in the lease), insurance for the property, and possibly maintenance costs for the property, depending on the contract arrangement.
How long do leases for land typically last?
Leasehold contracts often have very long terms, typically between 50 and 99 years. Shorter lease agreements are common with other types of leases (e.g., agricultural lease, recreational land) and vary greatly.
Is an increase in the lease payment possible during the contract term?
Yes, adjustments to ground rent are common in leasehold agreements, often linked to price indices (value retention clause). By law, adjustments are possible every 3 years, provided they are contractually agreed and not unreasonable.
What are the advantages of leasing compared to buying?
The main advantage of leasing is the lower initial capital requirement, as the high purchase price for the land is eliminated. This can make accessing a property easier, especially in expensive locations.
What are the advantages of buying over leasing?
The purchase leads to ownership and allows for asset building through appreciation and amortization. Owners have complete freedom in design and are independent of a landlord. In the long term, housing costs may decrease once the loan is paid off.
