Are you looking for stable values in uncertain times? Luxury investments offer a unique opportunity, but the market has its own rules. This guide shows you how to unlock return potentials with the right strategy and accurate assessments, while avoiding costly mistakes.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
Luxury investments showed mixed results in 2023: Art increased by 11% and jewellery rose by 8%, while the overall market slightly declined.
Long-term returns are high (e.g. whisky +280% in 10 years) but are associated with risks such as illiquidity and volatility.
Profits from sales are often tax-free in Germany after a holding period of one year (§ 23 EStG).
How can you protect and grow your wealth when traditional markets are volatile? Many investors turn to luxury investments, from rare watches to classic wine. These tangible assets promise not only emotional but also financial returns. The Knight Frank Luxury Investment Index shows a 100% increase in value over 10 years. However, the market cooled in 2023 with a slight drop of 1%, highlighting the need for a clear strategy. This article guides you through the opportunities and risks and explains why a data-driven neutral valuation is the key to success.
Market Overview: Which Luxury Goods Yield the Highest Returns?
The market for luxury investments showed a mixed performance in 2023. While the overall index, according to Knight Frank, declined by 1%, individual categories achieved remarkable gains. Art led the rankings with a value increase of 11%, followed by jewellery at 8% and watches at 5%. The long-term record is even more impressive: Over the last ten years, the value of rare whiskies has increased by 280% and that of fine wines by 146%. These figures demonstrate the significant potential inherent in tangible assets. However, the recent cooling, with classic cars correcting by about 6% and whisky by 9%, highlights the importance of accurate market analysis for luxury goods. Performance depends heavily on the particular segment and timing. Therefore, the right selection is crucial for investment success.
Analysis of the Top Asset Classes: Focus on Watches, Art, and Wine
Certain categories of luxury investments have proven to be particularly resilient and profitable. The pre-owned luxury watch market grew to a value of 24 billion US dollars in 2022 and is expected to increase to 35 billion US dollars by 2026. Art remains a favourite, with a Picasso piece auctioned for 139.4 million US dollars in 2023, highlighting the enormous value concentration in individual pieces. Wine and whisky also offer solid but differing returns. While wine increased by 146% over 10 years, whisky recently experienced a correction after a phenomenal run. A thorough understanding of value drivers is essential. The following factors significantly determine the price:
Rarity and Provenance: Limited editions or famous provenance can increase value by up to 50%.
Condition: Original condition and a complete maintenance history are crucial.
Brand Demand: Brands like Rolex or Patek Philippe consistently fetch high prices on the secondary market.
Cultural Relevance: Items with historical or cultural significance often achieve record prices.
These factors clearly indicate that investing without in-depth expertise, akin to that required for an appraisal of luxury real estate, is risky.
Hidden Risks: Volatility, Illiquidity, and High Ancillary Costs
Despite the attractive returns, luxury investments carry specific risks that are often underestimated. The markets are significantly less liquid than stock markets; selling can take weeks or months and involves high transaction costs of 15-25%. Fashion trends can heavily influence prices, leading to high volatility. For instance, handbags, once a top performer, lost about 4% in value in 2023. Additionally, the market is not very transparent, making it susceptible to counterfeiting and fraud, particularly with vintage cars and art. Therefore, careful risk assessment is essential. Consider the following points before investing:
Verify authenticity and provenance through recognised experts.
Factor in all ancillary costs such as storage, insurance, and appraisals, which can account for 1-2% of the value annually.
Plan for a long investment horizon of at least 5-10 years.
Diversify your portfolio and don't put all your investments into a single asset class.
A clear understanding of these risks will help you make secure investment decisions and protect your capital.
The crucial role of neutral evaluation
How do you ensure that the price for a luxury item is fair? An independent, data-driven evaluation is the most important protection against overpriced purchases and unrealistic expectations. Auction houses or dealers often have a vested interest, which can lead to skewed estimates. A neutral analysis, like the one Auctoa offers, is purely based on market data and algorithms. This eliminates conflicts of interest and provides an objective value. Especially in cases of inheritances or sales decisions, it prevents future conflicts and ensures financial clarity. Need a quick assessment? Our ImmoGPT chat can provide an initial orientation before you consult an expert in luxury goods. This way, you establish a solid foundation for any negotiation.
Tax Aspects in Germany: Handling Profits Correctly
Profits from the sale of luxury goods may be taxable in Germany. The decisive factor is the so-called speculation period, which is regulated in § 23 of the Income Tax Act. For most movable luxury items such as watches, art, or jewellery, there is a holding period of one year. If you sell such an item after this period, the profit is completely tax-free. If you make a profit within a year, this falls under private sales transactions. From 2024 onwards, there is an allowance of €1,000 per year for this. If your total profit from all private sales is below this threshold, you pay no taxes. If the threshold is exceeded, the entire profit is taxable. Accurate documentation of purchase date and price is therefore essential for every investor in order to correctly determine the tax burden and follow valuation guidelines.
Conclusion: Achieving Successful Luxury Investments with Data and Expertise
Luxury investments are a valuable addition to a diversified portfolio, but they require more than just capital. Success depends on deep market knowledge, a realistic assessment of risks, and above all, precise, independent valuation. The performance of recent years proves the potential, but the latest corrections urge caution. Rely on a data-driven strategy instead of gut feeling. With a professional valuation by specialized appraisers, you lay the foundation for long-term success in the complex luxury goods market. Your next investment begins with a solid figure.
luxusinvestments
Additional useful links
The Federal Statistical Office provides comprehensive data on income, consumption, living conditions, wealth, and debt in Germany, relevant to understanding the economic environment of luxury investments.
A study by the Deutsche Bundesbank analyses the development of wealth in Germany, including nominal and real changes as well as wealth inequality.
Bain & Company releases a press release on the current luxury goods study 2024 in Germany, delivering key market trends and forecasts.
Statista offers a detailed outlook on the luxury goods market in Germany, including forecasts and segment analyses.
The Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action (BMWK) provides the 2024 monitoring report on the cultural and creative industries in Germany, also offering relevant insights into the art and luxury market.
Statista delivers statistics on the price development of classic cars in Germany, based on the classic car index.
FAQ
Do I need an appraisal for my luxury investment?
Yes, an independent assessment is essential. It protects you from inflated prices when buying, provides a realistic basis for selling, and is often necessary for insurance. A neutral, data-driven evaluation gives you negotiating confidence.
Which luxury watch is a good investment?
Models from established brands like Rolex, Patek Philippe, and Audemars Piguet have historically proven to be very stable in value. Limited editions or models with a special history, in particular, often achieve high returns on the secondary market, which is expected to grow to 35 billion USD by 2026.
How can I verify the authenticity of a luxury item?
Authenticity checks should always be conducted by certified experts or the manufacturer themselves. Pay attention to official documents, certificates, and an unbroken provenance (ownership history). If in doubt, it is better to refrain from purchasing.
Are there any ongoing costs for luxury investments?
Yes, ongoing costs are an important factor. These include insurance, professional storage (e.g., in a wine cellar or safe), maintenance (for watches or cars), and possible re-assessments. These can amount to 1-2% of the item's value annually.
Is art a safe investment?
In 2023, art was the best-performing asset class in the KFLII with an 11% increase. However, the market can be very volatile and subjective. The value depends heavily on the artist, the era, and the provenance. Therefore, investing in art requires deep expertise or professional advice.
