Consultation
Insurance
Underinsurance Risks
Underinsurance can have devastating financial consequences. Be proactive! This article shows you how to determine the correct insurance amount and which risks you can avoid. Do you need personal advice? Contact us for a non-binding analysis of your insurance situation.
Underinsurance carries significant financial risks, as in the event of a claim, the insurance benefits are reduced. Regularly reviewing the insured sum is essential.
A faulty valuation is a major cause of underinsurance. Professional appraisals and the consideration of increases in value are essential to minimize this risk.
AI-based systems offer great potential for the improvement of valuation in the future, but they also pose ethical challenges. The integration of AI can improve accuracy by up to 20%.
Definition and Meaning of Underinsurance
Underinsurance occurs when the agreed insurance sum is lower than the actual value of the insured object. This means that in the event of a claim, the entire loss is not covered. In contrast, overinsurance is where the insurance sum exceeds the actual value, but this does not lead to a higher payout in the event of a claim. It is crucial to understand the difference between these concepts and correct insurance to minimise financial risks. Correct insurance ensures that the insurance sum matches the actual value, so that the entire loss is covered in the event of a claim. Therefore, a regular review of the insurance sum is essential.
The Relevance of Underinsurance in German Insurance Law
Underinsurance is a central issue in German insurance law, as it can have significant financial implications for policyholders. The legal foundations, particularly § 75 of the Insurance Contract Act (VVG), regulate the reduction of insurance benefits in the event of underinsurance. This means that policyholders only receive a portion of the damage in the event of a claim, which can jeopardise their financial stability. Therefore, it is of great importance for both policyholders and insurers to recognise and avoid the risk of underinsurance. Comprehensive risk assessment can help to minimise potential dangers.
Correct valuation is crucial to minimising the risks of underinsurance. Inaccurate valuation may result in the insurance sum being set too low, leading to substantial financial losses in the event of a claim. It is therefore advisable to seek professional assistance to determine the actual value of the insured object. This is especially true for properties and other valuable assets. Avoiding gaps in coverage is another important aspect to ensure no unexpected costs arise in the event of a claim.
Underestimation of Actual Value
One of the main causes of underinsurance is the incorrect valuation of the insured object. Often the actual value is underestimated due to a lack of expertise or incorrect assumptions. For example, in the case of properties, the value of modernisations or extensions might not be adequately considered. When it comes to household contents, new acquisitions or valuables are often forgotten. This underestimation leads to the insurance sum being set too low, resulting in significant financial losses in the event of a claim. It is therefore important to carry out a realistic and comprehensive valuation to minimise the risks of underinsurance.
Typical mistakes in valuation include ignoring value increases due to inflation, overlooking valuables in household goods, or misjudging the condition of a property. These errors can lead to the insurance sum being significantly below the actual value. To avoid such mistakes, it is advisable to regularly commission professional appraisals and adjust the insurance sum accordingly. Careful documentation of all valuables and modernisations is also essential. The risks of underinsurance should not be underestimated.
Dynamic Increases in Value and Lack of Adjustment of the Insurance Sum
Dynamic increases in value through inflation and modernisation also play a crucial role in the creation of underinsurance. The value of properties and inventories can increase significantly over time, be it through general price rises or specific improvements to the object. If the insurance amount is not regularly adjusted to these value increases, underinsurance occurs. The effects of inflation can be particularly significant in long-term insurance contracts. It is therefore important to regularly review and, if necessary, adjust the insurance sum to ensure that the actual value of the insured object is always adequately covered.
The need for regular adjustment of the insurance sum is often underestimated. Many policyholders assume that their insurance is automatically adjusted for value increases, which is not always the case. It is therefore advisable to regularly contact the insurance broker and review the insurance sum. An index adjustment can provide automatic adjustment of the insurance sum, but should still be regularly reviewed to ensure that it matches the actual value increases. Regular evaluation is therefore essential.
Inadequate Advice from Insurance Brokers
Another cause of underinsurance can be inadequate advice from insurance brokers. If insurance brokers do not adequately inform about the consequences of underinsurance or do not conduct a comprehensive needs analysis, this can lead to policyholders unknowingly being underinsured. It is the responsibility of the insurance broker to fully inform the policyholder and help them choose the appropriate insurance sum. Insufficient information can have serious financial consequences for the policyholder. It is therefore important to choose a competent and trustworthy insurance broker who conducts an individual needs analysis and transparently outlines the risks of underinsurance.
A comprehensive needs analysis should consider all relevant factors, such as the value of the property, the value of the household goods, individual risk factors, and the policyholder's financial capabilities. The insurance broker should present various options to the policyholder and help them choose appropriate insurance products and conditions. It is advisable not only to rely on the recommendations of the insurance broker but also to independently gather information and compare various offers. Risk assessment should therefore be conducted both by the insurance broker and the policyholder.
Reduction of Insurance Benefits in Case of Damage (§ 75 VVG)
The legal consequences of underinsurance are clearly regulated in German insurance law. According to § 75 of the German Insurance Contract Act (VVG), the insurance benefit can be reduced in the event of a claim if underinsurance is present. This means that the insurer does not compensate for the entire damage, but only a portion corresponding to the ratio between the sum insured and the actual value of the insured object. This proportional claims settlement can lead to considerable financial losses for the policyholder. Therefore, it is crucial to understand and avoid the risks of underinsurance.
The basis for calculating the reduction in insurance benefits is relatively simple: if the sum insured only covers 50% of the actual value, then only 50% of the damage will be compensated. In individual cases, this could mean that the policyholder has to bear a significant portion of the damage themselves. To prevent this, it is advisable to regularly review and, if necessary, adjust the sum insured. Avoiding coverage gaps is an important step in minimizing financial risks.
Burden of Proof and Duties of the Policyholder
In the event of underinsurance, the policyholder carries the burden of proof for the actual value of the insured object. This means that the policyholder must prove that the object's value was higher than the agreed insurance sum. This can be challenging in the event of a claim, especially if there is insufficient documentation. Therefore, it is important to carefully document and regularly review the value of the insured object. The responsibility for determining and documenting the value thus lies with the policyholder. The risks of underinsurance should therefore be taken seriously.
The requirements for documenting the insured value are high. It is advisable to create a detailed inventory list with photos and receipts and to update this regularly. In the event of damage, this documentation can serve as proof of the actual value. If the policyholder breaches their duties, for example by not sufficiently documenting the object's value, this may lead to a reduction in insurance benefits. It is therefore important to know and comply with the policyholder's duties.
Legal Disputes and Case Law
Legal disputes related to underinsurance are not uncommon. Policyholders and insurers often argue about the amount of insurance benefits and whether underinsurance is present. Case law on this subject is diverse and complex. Current judgments can provide important insights into how courts decide in such cases. It is therefore advisable to stay informed about current case law and seek legal advice if necessary. The BGH judgments on private expert reports play a significant role here, as they highlight the importance of expert reports in determining value.
Relevant decisions regarding residual value determination are also important, especially in the case of motor vehicle damage. The courts have clarified in various judgments the requirements for residual value determination and which costs are reimbursable. These decisions can be relevant for both policyholders and insurers. It is therefore important to stay informed about current case law and, if necessary, seek legal advice to understand your rights and obligations.
Property Insurance: Underinsurance in Residential Buildings
In property insurance, underinsurance is a common issue. Many policyholders underestimate the value of their residential building, particularly if renovations or extensions have been undertaken. These increases in value are often not adequately considered, which can result in underinsurance in the event of a claim. An example could be a homeowner who insured their property 20 years ago and has since carried out extensive renovations without adjusting the sum insured. In the case of a fire, the insurance would only cover the original value of the house, not the cost of the renovations. Therefore, it is important to regularly adjust the sum insured to reflect the current value of the residential property.
An up-to-date calculation of the living area is also significant, as the living area is an important factor in valuation. If the living area is incorrectly stated, it can lead to underinsurance. It is therefore advisable to regularly check and, if necessary, correct the living area. Regular assessments are crucial to minimise the risks of underinsurance.
Contents Insurance: Underinsurance in Inventory
Underinsurance is also a frequent issue in contents insurance. Many policyholders underestimate the value of their belongings, especially when new purchases or valuable items are involved. These valuables are often not sufficiently considered, resulting in underinsurance in the event of a claim. An example could be a policyholder who has acquired valuable art objects or jewellery over the years without adjusting the sum insured. In the event of a burglary, the insurance would only replace the original value of the household items, not the value of the art objects or jewellery. Therefore, it is important to regularly adjust the sum insured to reflect the current value of the household items.
A detailed inventory list is also important, as it can serve as proof of the value of the household items. If no inventory list is available, it may be difficult to prove the value of the household items in the event of a claim. It is therefore advisable to create a detailed inventory list with photos and receipts and update it regularly. Avoiding coverage gaps is a key step in minimising financial risks.
Commercial Insurance: Underinsurance in Companies
Underinsurance is also a common issue in commercial insurance. Companies often underestimate the value of their premises, machinery, and stock. These valuable items are often not sufficiently considered, leading to underinsurance in the event of a claim. An example could be a company that has acquired new machinery over the years without adjusting the sum insured. In the case of a fire, the insurance would only replace the original value of the machinery, not the value of the new machines. Therefore, it is important to regularly adjust the sum insured to reflect the current value of premises, machinery, and stock.
Regular inventories and appraisals are also significant, as they can serve as proof of the value of the premises, machinery, and stock. If no inventory and appraisal are conducted, proving the value of the premises, machinery, and stock in the event of a claim can be challenging. It is therefore advisable to conduct regular inventories and appraisals and adjust the sum insured accordingly. Risk assessments should therefore be carried out regularly.
Regular Valuation and Adjustment of the Insurance Sum
One of the most important strategies for avoiding underinsurance is the regular valuation and adjustment of the insurance sum. The value of real estate, household contents, and business assets can change significantly over time, whether due to inflation, modernisation, or new acquisitions. If the insurance sum is not regularly adjusted to these changes in value, underinsurance arises. Therefore, it is advisable to regularly review the value of the insured objects and adjust the insurance sum accordingly.
Professional appraisals by experts can help determine the actual value of the insured objects. An expert can objectively and independently assess the value of a property and create a well-founded valuation. An index adjustment can also ensure an automatic adjustment of the insurance sum, but it should still be regularly checked to ensure it corresponds with actual value increases. Regular evaluation is therefore essential.
Comprehensive Advice from Insurance Professionals
Another important strategy for avoiding underinsurance is comprehensive advice from insurance professionals. A qualified insurance expert can conduct an individual needs analysis and select the appropriate insurance products and conditions. They can also explain the consequences of underinsurance and assist in determining the correct insurance sum. It is therefore advisable to seek advice from an insurance expert to ensure that you are adequately insured.
An individual needs analysis should consider all relevant factors, such as the value of the property, the value of household contents, individual risk factors, and the financial capabilities of the policyholder. The insurance expert should present various options to the policyholder and assist them in selecting the appropriate insurance products and conditions. The risk assessment should therefore be conducted by both the insurance expert and the policyholder.
Documentation and Proof in the Event of a Claim
A detailed inventory list with photos and receipts can serve as proof of the value of the insured objects in the event of a claim. If no inventory list is available, it can be difficult to prove the value of the insured objects in the event of a claim. Therefore, it is advisable to create a detailed inventory list and update it regularly. The storage of important documents and evidence is also important, as they can serve as evidence in the event of a claim. Avoiding coverage gaps is an important step in minimising financial risks.
A detailed inventory list should include all valuables with a description, purchase date, and purchase price. Photos of the valuables can also be helpful in proving their value. Receipts for new acquisitions should be kept carefully. In the event of a claim, this documentation can serve as proof of the actual value of the insured objects. Therefore, it is important to create and store the documentation carefully.
Meaning of Private and Court-Appointed Expert Opinions
In the legal system, expert opinions play a crucial role in resolving disputes related to underinsurance. There are two types of expert opinions: private opinions and court-appointed opinions. Private opinions are commissioned by the parties themselves and serve as evidence. Court-appointed opinions are commissioned by the court to clarify contentious issues. Both types of opinions can be significant in assessing underinsurance. The BGH rulings on private opinions have enhanced their significance in the legal context.
The role of private opinions in providing evidence should not be underestimated. A private opinion can help prove the value of an insured object and support a party's argument. The role of court-appointed opinions in resolving disputed facts is also important. A court-appointed opinion can contribute to objectively and independently assessing the value of an insured object and making an informed decision. Therefore, understanding the significance of expert opinions in legal proceedings and commissioning one if necessary is essential.
Liability of Experts and Duties of Care
Experts bear significant responsibility when preparing expert opinions. They must perform their duties carefully and diligently, providing objective and independent assessments. If an expert intentionally or grossly negligently produces a flawed report, they can be held liable. § 839a BGB regulates the liability of experts for faulty reports. The § 839a BGB and the information sheet on the liability of court experts provide detailed information on this matter.
The duties of care in preparing expert opinions are stringent. Experts must thoroughly research, analyze, and formulate their reports. They must also consider the current legal framework. If an expert breaches their duties of care, they can be held liable for the damages caused by the faulty report. Therefore, selecting a qualified and experienced expert who performs their duties carefully and diligently is crucial.
Current Case Law on Residual Value Assessment and Expert Costs
The current case law on residual value assessment and expert costs is significant, especially concerning vehicle damage. Courts have clarified in various judgments the requirements for residual value assessment and which costs can be reimbursed. The case law on residual value assessment is diverse and complex. It is advisable to stay informed about current case law and seek legal advice if necessary.
The reimbursability of expert costs and cost estimates is also an essential aspect. Courts have ruled in various cases that costs for an expert opinion or estimate can be reimbursed if they were necessary for damage assessment. However, it is important that the costs are reasonable and not excessive. Therefore, it is wise to inform oneself about typical costs before commissioning an expert opinion or obtaining a cost estimate.
AI-based Support in Valuation
Artificial Intelligence (AI) offers new possibilities for support in valuation. AI-based systems can analyse large amounts of data and identify patterns relevant to valuation. This can lead to automation and increased efficiency in the valuation process. The application of AI for the automated valuation of real estate and inventory is a promising approach. The advantages of AI-based analysis of large data sets lie in the speed and accuracy of the analysis. AI systems can analyse large amounts of data in a short time and identify patterns that are relevant to valuation. This can result in more efficient and accurate valuations.
AI-based systems can, for example, analyse the value of comparable properties in real estate valuation and estimate the value of a property based on this analysis. In inventory valuation, AI-based systems can estimate the value of individual items and determine the total value of the inventory. The AI integration into the appraisal process is an important step towards the future.
Ethical Aspects and Challenges in the Use of AI
However, when using AI in valuation, ethical aspects and challenges must also be considered. AI systems can, for example, exhibit bias in algorithms, leading to distorted valuations. Data protection is also an important aspect, as personal data is processed in valuation. The necessity of human experts reviewing AI-based reports is therefore essential. The consideration of ethical aspects and data protection regulations is also significant.
To ensure that AI-based reports are objective and independent, they must be reviewed by human experts. These experts can critically question the results of the AI-based analysis and correct them if necessary. Data protection must also be ensured by processing personal data only within the framework of legal regulations. Risk assessment should therefore also take ethical aspects into account.
Future Developments and Potentials
The integration of AI into the entire appraisal process offers great potential in the future. AI can, for example, support research, analysis, and formulation of reports. The potentials of AI to improve the quality and efficiency of reports are enormous. AI-based systems can, for instance, extract relevant information from large data sets during research and recognise complex relationships during analysis. AI-based systems can also assist in the formulation of reports by generating text suggestions, for example.
The integration of AI in research, analysis, and formulation of reports can lead to more efficient and higher quality report creation. However, the potentials of AI are not yet fully realised. In the future, AI-based systems are expected to be even more integrated into the appraisal process and offer new possibilities for support in valuation. Regular assessment of technological developments is therefore indispensable.
Summary of Key Findings
Underinsurance presents a considerable financial risk arising from a discrepancy between the insurance sum and the actual value of the insured object. In the event of a claim, this can lead to significant financial losses, as the insurance benefits may be reduced accordingly. Therefore, it is essential to regularly review and adjust the insurance sum to ensure that the actual value of the insured object is always adequately covered. The financial risks of underinsurance should not be underestimated, and avoiding coverage gaps is a crucial step in minimizing financial risks.
Recommendations for Policyholders and Insurance Brokers
To minimize the risks of underinsurance, policyholders and insurance brokers should adhere to the following recommendations:
Regular Valuation and Adjustment of the Insurance Sum: The value of insured objects should be regularly assessed, and the insurance sum adjusted accordingly.
Comprehensive Advice from Insurance Professionals: Policyholders should seek advice from a qualified insurance professional to select the appropriate insurance products and conditions.
Documentation and Proof in Case of Damage: A detailed inventory list with photos and receipts can serve as proof of the value of insured objects in the event of a claim.
A checklist to avoid underinsurance should contain the following points: Regular valuation and adjustment of the insurance sum, comprehensive advice from insurance professionals, and documentation and proof in case of damage. Risk assessments should therefore be conducted regularly.
Outlook on Future Developments in Insurance Law
Digitization and AI will significantly impact the insurance industry in the future. New technologies offer new opportunities for support in valuation and risk assessment. However, the need for transparent and understandable communication with policyholders will remain important. The trends and challenges in insurance law are diverse and complex. It is therefore important to keep informed about current developments and, if necessary, seek legal advice.
The significance of digitization and AI for the insurance industry lies in the increased efficiency and automation of processes. The necessity for transparent and understandable communication with policyholders arises from the complexity of insurance products and conditions. Thus, it is vital that policyholders understand the risks and opportunities of digitization and AI and seek advice accordingly. Regular assessment of technological developments is therefore essential.
Government grants and support programs offer you an excellent opportunity to optimally protect your assets and minimize financial risks. Enter offers comprehensive advice and support in selecting the appropriate insurance products, fulfilling all necessary requirements, and navigating the entire process. By choosing the right insurance solution, you not only secure your assets but also benefit from long-term financial security.
Take the opportunity now to gain comprehensive information about your insurance options. Contact us today to arrange a personal consultation and discuss your individual needs. Register for free and receive an immediate assessment of your insurance requirements.
Underinsurance poses significant risks to your wealth. By misjudging the value and failing to adjust the insured amount, you risk bearing the majority of the costs in the event of a claim. It is, therefore, crucial to act proactively and protect your wealth from the consequences of underinsurance effectively. A regular review and adjustment of your insurance policy are essential to avoid financial losses. Find out now about the options for a professional valuation and an adjustable new-for-old insurance.
Auctoa is revolutionising the valuation of properties and real estate by utilising the latest in automation and AI-supported human expertise. We provide you with precise, certified, and market-appropriate valuations that help you determine the correct insured amount and optimally protect your wealth. Our fully automated valuation platforms, hybrid AI-human assessments, and digital market analyses ensure the highest accuracy and speed in determining the true value of real estate.
Invest in the security of your wealth and avoid the financial risks of underinsurance. Contact us today for personalised advice and learn how we can help you optimally adjust your insured amount. Register for free and receive an immediate first estimate of your property's value. Contact us now!
The Bundesbank offers detailed statistics on finance and wealth.
The Bundesministerium der Finanzen provides information on wealth tax in Germany.
What does underinsurance mean and how does it occur?
Underinsurance exists when the insured sum is lower than the actual value of the insured object. It often arises due to faulty valuation, lack of adjustment for value increases, or insufficient advice.
What legal consequences does underinsurance have in the event of a claim?
According to § 75 VVG, the insurance benefit can be reduced in the event of a claim if underinsurance exists. The insurer then only covers part of the damage, in proportion to the relationship between the insured sum and the actual value.
How can I correctly determine the value of my property to avoid underinsurance?
Regularly obtain professional appraisals, take into account value increases due to modernisations, and adjust the insured sum accordingly. An up-to-date calculation of living space is also important.
What role do insurance brokers play in avoiding underinsurance?
Insurance brokers should conduct a comprehensive needs analysis, inform about the consequences of underinsurance, and assist in selecting the appropriate insured sum.
What is the significance of private appraisals and court appraisals in case of dispute over underinsurance?
Private appraisals serve as evidence to demonstrate the value of an insured object. Court appraisals are commissioned by the court to clarify disputed issues. Both can be relevant in assessing underinsurance.
How does current case law affect the residual value determination in vehicle damage in the context of underinsurance?
The case law specifies which requirements are placed on residual value determination and which costs are refundable. This is particularly important to obtain adequate compensation in the event of a claim.
What role does AI play in future valuation and avoidance of underinsurance?
AI-based systems can analyse large amounts of data and identify patterns relevant to valuation. This can lead to automation and increased efficiency, but also poses ethical challenges.
What are the key recommendations for avoiding underinsurance?
Regular valuation, comprehensive advice from insurance professionals, and detailed documentation of the insured assets are crucial to avoid underinsurance.
