Are you losing market share to more agile competitors? A precise competitive analysis in the insurance market is not a luxury, but a crucial tool for risk minimization and strategic positioning. Discover how you can use data-driven methods to refine your offerings and become more profitable.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
The loss ratio in building insurance stood at 103.3% in 2023, highlighting the need for strategic adjustments.
The share of digital insurance contracts increased to 19.1% by 2023, making the analysis of online competitors essential.
Structured methods like the SWOT analysis and Porter's Five Forces model are crucial for turning data into actionable strategies.
Are you facing the challenge of defending your market position in an increasingly fragmented insurance market? Digitalisation has changed the rules: 79% of Germans have already taken out insurance online, which increases the pressure on traditional sales models. A systematic competitive analysis is the compass you need to navigate this complex environment. This article shows you how structured analyses can not only identify risks but also derive concrete growth strategies to outperform your competitors based on data.
Understanding Market Dynamics: The Foundation for Strategic Decisions
The German insurance market is characterized by intense competition and low margins. In property insurance, expenses exceeded revenue, resulting in a loss ratio of 103.3% in 2023. Such metrics indicate that continuing as before is not an option. A thorough competitive analysis of the insurance market uncovers unprofitable areas and identifies niches with growth potential. Analyzing the current market trends is the first step to review one's own positioning. Only those who understand the strategies, products, and pricing models of competitors can successfully adapt their own offerings. This data-driven foundation is crucial not only for reacting to market changes but for proactively shaping the market.
The Digital Transformation: Online Channels as the New Battleground
Digitalisation has fundamentally changed customer behaviour and significantly intensified online competition. The proportion of insurance contracts completed digitally rose to 19.1% by 2023, a marked increase from 15.3% in 2021. Almost 80% of Germans have already taken out insurance online, with 56% using comparison portals. These figures demonstrate that digital presence decides success or failure. Therefore, a modern competitive analysis must include online visibility, as examined in the SEO benchmark for insurers. A well-thought-out insurance strategy must optimise digital touchpoints to reach the growing online-affine target group. Analysing the digital customer journey of your competitors provides the blueprint for optimising your own sales channels.
Methods and tools for precise analysis
An effective competitive analysis requires a structured approach rather than mere observation. Established models provide a clear framework for this. The SWOT analysis helps assess your strengths and weaknesses in direct comparison to the market's opportunities and threats. Porter's Five Forces model analyses the entire industry dynamics, including the bargaining power of customers and suppliers, as well as the threat from new entrants and substitute products. These tools transform raw data into strategic insights. A list of key analysis steps includes:
Identifying the 3-5 most important competitors.
Analysing the product and service offerings of the competition.
Comparing price and terms models.
Evaluating marketing and sales channels (online and offline).
Analysing online visibility and social media activities.
Identifying technological capabilities (e.g. app usage, AI in service).
A systematic risk management, as is central in real estate valuation, is based on precisely such structured analyses.
Accessing data sources: Where the crucial information comes from
The quality of a competitive analysis directly depends on the quality of the underlying data. Fortunately, there are numerous sources to provide a comprehensive picture. The German Insurance Association (Gesamtverband der Deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft - GDV) publishes detailed industry statistics annually. Competitors' annual reports offer insights into their strategic direction and financial performance. Trade magazines and market studies, such as those by Bitkom on digitalisation, provide current trend assessments. Digital analysis tools, which provide data on online performance, are particularly valuable. They show which keywords competitors rank with and what their online reputation is like. Similar to how Auctoa makes the real estate market transparent for users with ImmoGPT, you can use these tools to decipher the insurance market for your strategic planning. The combination of these sources allows a 360-degree view of the competition.
From Analysis to Action: Deriving and Implementing Strategies
An analysis is only as good as the actions that follow. The insights gained must lead to concrete business decisions. If the analysis shows that a competitor is successful with an innovative, modular product, this could serve as an impetus for your own product development. If it turns out that your own brand is underrepresented on comparison portals, sales partnerships need to be adjusted. A list of possible areas for action:
Product Innovation: Development of new tariffs that fill a market gap overlooked by competitors.
Price Optimisation: Adjustment of price structure based on the target audience's willingness to pay and the competitor's price points.
Sales Strategy: Strengthening the channels where the target audience is most active, for example, by investing in direct sales via the website.
Marketing and Communication: Refining the brand message to clearly differentiate the unique selling propositions (USPs) from the competition.
These risk mitigation strategies are key to sustainably strengthening your own market position.
Conclusion: Continuous analysis as a driver for sustainable growth
Competitor analysis in the insurance market is not a one-off project, but a continuous process. The market is dynamically changing due to new technologies, customer requirements, and regulatory mandates. Companies that continuously monitor their competitors and the market environment can respond more quickly to changes and proactively seize opportunities. Regular analysis reduces the risk of wrong decisions by over 20%. It lays the foundation for agile corporate management. If you are unsure how to use data-driven analysis for your decisions, a conversation with experts can help. The ImmoGPT chat by Auctoa, for instance, offers immediate, data-based answers for the real estate sector – a principle that also applies to your competitive strategy in the insurance sector.
wettbewerbsanalysen-versicherungsmarkt
Additional useful links
Statista offers a comprehensive overview of the insurance market in Germany.
GDV provides a summary of statistics on the German insurance industry.
Statista displays statistics on the top 20 German insurance companies.
PwC offers a study on the transformation of core insurance systems.
Oliver Wyman provides an outlook on the insurance sector in 2030.
GDV offers facts and figures on the insurance industry in 2024 as a PDF download.
Deutsche Bundesbank provides statistics on insurance companies.
Destatis supplies structural data on service sectors.
FAQ
How often should a competitive analysis in the insurance sector be conducted?
Due to the high market dynamics, continuous monitoring is recommended. A comprehensive, in-depth analysis should be conducted at least once a year, while key indicators such as online visibility and price changes should be reviewed quarterly.
What tools can I use for a competitive analysis?
You can use a combination of industry reports (e.g., from the GDV), competitor financial reports, and digital SEO tools (e.g., Sistrix, Ahrefs) to analyze online presence. Customer surveys and test purchases are also valuable tools.
What is the difference between market analysis and competitor analysis?
The market analysis considers the entire market, including market size, growth trends and customer segments. The competitive analysis is a part of this and specifically focuses on the strategies, strengths, and weaknesses of direct competitors.
How can I identify the strengths and weaknesses of my competitors?
Analyse their products, read customer reviews on portals, examine their business reports, and observe their marketing campaigns. A SWOT analysis is an excellent tool to assess this information systematically.
How can Auctoa assist me with the analysis even though it concerns insurance?
Auctoa is an expert in data-driven analysis and evaluations in the real estate sector. The principles of precise data collection and strategic evaluation for risk minimisation are directly transferable to other industries. Our ImmoGPT demonstrates how AI-powered tools make complex data understandable – an approach that is also crucial for competitive analysis in the insurance market.
