Have you inherited or acquired a property with an old building? This situation presents enormous opportunities, but also financial risks of over €100,000. We will show you how to systematically develop the best strategy for your property.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
Evaluate cost-effectiveness: Demolition is generally more sensible if the renovation costs exceed 75% of the cost of a comparable new construction.
Calculate costs realistically: Budget €10,000 to €30,000 for demolition and consider additional costs for hazardous waste disposal.
Clarify legal hurdles early on: Check the development plan and any potential listed building status before making financial commitments.
An existing property presents owners with a complex decision: renovate, demolish and rebuild, or sell directly? Each option has significant financial and legal implications. Renovation can preserve the charm, but costs can escalate, while demolition and reconstruction offer planning security, yet are associated with demolition costs alone ranging from €150 to €200 per square metre. This article provides you with a well-informed, data-backed basis for decision-making to maximise the value of your property and avoid costly mistakes. We analyse the critical factors – from building structure to building regulations to subsidies – and provide you with clear recommendations for action.
In brief: Your options for action
The decision about the future of a property with existing buildings depends on three key factors: the condition of the building, planning permission, and your budget. Renovation is often more expensive than expected; if costs exceed 75% of a new build, demolition is usually more economical. Demolition costs typically range from €10,000 to €30,000, but can increase significantly if there are hazardous materials. A new build offers maximum design freedom and energy efficiency, but requires an investment of approximately €2,200 to €3,000 per square metre. The careful assessment of all factors is the first step towards a profitable decision.
Step 1: In-depth inventory analysis as a basis
Before making a decision, a professional analysis of the status quo is essential. A building surveyor examines the structural integrity and condition of the building for approximately €500 to €2,000. Particular caution is needed with buildings from the 1950s to 1970s as they often contain hazardous materials like asbestos. A soil survey costing around €900 determines if hidden contaminants in the soil are present, the removal of which can incur costs in the tens of thousands. These initial investments in surveys protect you from incalculable consequential costs of tens of thousands of euros. The results of these examinations form the basis for further strategic planning.
Option A: Demolition – When a Total Clearance is Worthwhile
A demolition is the right choice when the building structure is dilapidated or when a renovation would consume more than 75% of the new building costs. The pure demolition costs for an average single-family house range from €150 to €200 per square metre. However, the total costs are influenced by several factors.
An overview of the most important cost factors:
Building size and type: Demolishing a house with a basement is up to 30% more expensive.
Accessibility of the site: Narrow access roads can complicate the use of heavy machinery and increase costs by 10-15%.
Pollution: The disposal of asbestos or old oil tanks can increase costs by €5,000 to €15,000.
Disposal: The rubble from a single-family house can quickly amount to 300 to 400 cubic metres, with disposal costing several thousand euros.
Demolition creates a clean foundation for a new build, tailored exactly to your desires and modern energy standards. This clarity is a decisive advantage compared to the uncertainties of renovation.
Option B: The Renovation – Preserving Charm, Controlling Costs
Renovation preserves the character of a property and is often more resource-efficient than new construction. However, the costs are highly dependent on the condition. A complete renovation can cost between €800 and €1,500 per square metre, reaching the costs of new construction. Energetic renovations are heavily subsidised by the government.
Typical renovation measures and their eligibility for funding:
Roof renovation, including insulation: Costs range from €20,000 to €50,000, but up to 20% grant available via BAFA or KfW.
Facade insulation: Expect costs of €150 to €250 per square metre; here, grants of 15-20% are also available.
Window replacement: Modern triple-glazed windows cost around €800 each, but improve the energy balance by up to 15%.
Heating system replacement: Switching to a heat pump costs approximately €25,000 to €40,000, but is subsidised by up to 70%.
Carefully assess beforehand which measures are necessary for efficient modernisation. A professional energy consultation, which is also subsidised, is essential here for setting the right priorities.
Legal Framework: What Building Law Prescribes
Your plans must always operate within the legal framework. Consulting the local development plan is the first indispensable step. It dictates what can be built on your property – from the roof shape to the number of storeys. In most federal states, a demolition permit is not required for buildings under 300 cubic metres in volume; however, an informal notification to the building authority is often necessary. Particular caution is required with regard to listed buildings. If the building is protected, changes are only possible in close coordination with the monument conservation authority, and demolition is almost impossible. These requirements can increase renovation costs by 20-30% but offer tax deduction advantages. Be sure to clarify these legal risks before purchasing or planning.
The Financing and Valuation Matrix
The right strategy largely depends on the valuation and financing options available. The value of a property with existing buildings is primarily determined by the standard land value. However, you need to mentally deduct demolition and any potential renovation costs from this value. A demolition property can reduce the land value by €20,000 to €30,000. For renovations and energy-efficient new buildings, KfW and BAFA offer low-interest loans (up to €150,000) and repayment grants (up to 45%). A precise valuation by experts like Auctoa helps you to recognize the full potential. With our ImmoGPT, you can play through initial scenarios free of charge and data-supported, to provide a solid basis for decision-making.
grundstuck-mit-altbestand
The question of what should happen to a plot with existing buildings cannot be answered universally. A thorough analysis of the building fabric, building regulations, and costs is crucial. As a general rule, if the renovation costs exceed 75% of the new construction costs, demolition is usually the more economically viable option. Be sure to obtain expert opinions from building surveyors and architects and use digital tools for an initial assessment. This way, you can turn a complex problem into a clear, value-enhancing strategy. Your decision today lays the foundation for the value of your property for the next 30 years.
Additional useful links
Das Statistische Bundesamt (Destatis) offers current data on construction prices and the Property Price Index.
Statista provides comprehensive statistics on real estate prices across all construction years in Germany.
Der ZIA (Zentraler Immobilien Ausschuss) publishes its Spring Report 2024 with detailed analyses of the real estate market.
Die KfW (Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau) provides information on funding opportunities for the renovation and modernization of existing properties.
Wikipedia offers an overview of demolition in construction.
Wikipedia explains the concept of renovation in construction.
Wikipedia provides basic information about the real estate market in Germany.
FAQ
What does 'property with existing structure' mean?
A plot with existing structures is a parcel of land on which one or more older buildings are located. These buildings often require renovation, do not meet current building standards, or obstruct new development.
What permits do I need for a demolition?
This varies from state to state. Generally, buildings with an enclosed space of less than 300 cubic metres do not require formal approval, but a demolition notice to the relevant building authority is necessary. For larger or listed buildings, a permit is always required.
Can I use the basement of the old house for the new construction?
This is technically possible, but often not advisable. Old cellars are frequently damp, poorly insulated, and do not meet the structural requirements of a modern new building. Renovating an old cellar can be more expensive than a complete new construction of the foundation.
Who is liable for contamination on the property?
In principle, the owner is liable for dangers emanating from their property, even if they did not cause the contamination. Therefore, it is extremely important to check for contaminated sites before purchasing to avoid being left with remediation costs amounting to tens of thousands of euros.
What role does the standard land value play?
The standard land value is an average value for plots in a specific location and serves as an initial guide for the property value. However, the actual market value of your plot may vary, depending on factors such as buildability, layout, and the condition of existing structures (demolition costs reduce the value).
How can Auctoa assist with the decision-making process?
Auctoa provides an AI-powered, neutral real estate valuation that takes into account all relevant factors, including potential demolition or renovation costs. Our ImmoGPT enables you to quickly analyse various scenarios and obtain a data-driven foundation for your strategic decision.
