Are you facing an important real estate decision and need a reliable basis for valuation? An expert opinion is often the key to avoiding costly mistakes and knowing the fair value of your property. Discover how expert opinions can provide you with more security through data-driven analyses.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
An expert opinion (property appraisal) is crucial for fair and secure real estate transactions and is based on legal foundations such as the BauGB and ImmoWertV.
The cost of an appraisal (starting at approximately 500 euros for a brief report, up to 1.5% of the property value for a full report) is an important investment to avoid costly mistakes.
The selection of a qualified expert (e.g., publicly appointed and sworn in, or certified according to DIN EN ISO/IEC 17024) is essential for the reliability of the expert opinion.
A real estate transaction, whether purchase, sale, or inheritance matter, represents a significant financial decision for most parties involved. Each year, over 1 million real estate contracts are notarized in Germany, highlighting the enormous economic importance. [3] Given this significance, an informed expert opinion is essential to minimize risks and ensure fair pricing. Without an objective assessment, you risk either overpaying or selling your property below its value. This article explores how an expert opinion helps you make informed decisions to optimally safeguard your financial interests.
Understanding the Role of Expert Opinion in Real Estate
An expert opinion, often referred to as an expert report, is a well-founded assessment of a property's value by a qualified expert. [1] These experts, also known as property valuers, use recognised methods to objectively determine the market value. In Germany, the term 'expert' is not legally protected outside of the designation 'publicly appointed and sworn' (ö.b.u.v.), making the careful selection of an expert all the more important. [1] A professional valuation is based on detailed facts and takes into account numerous factors such as location, condition, and legal framework. [2] The Real Estate Valuation Ordinance (ImmoWertV) forms the legal basis for this in Germany and was comprehensively revised in 2022. [2] An expert opinion provides transparency and a solid basis for negotiations, which is invaluable, especially in complex situations such as inheritances or divorces. [1]
Precisely apply legal principles and recognized evaluation methods
The determination of the market value of a property is defined in § 194 of the Building Code (BauGB). [4] This paragraph specifies that the market value is determined by the price that could be achieved at a specific time in the ordinary course of business. The Property Valuation Ordinance (ImmoWertV) clarifies these guidelines and regulates the applicable valuation methods. [2] There are three standardised main procedures:
The comparative value method: This involves using actual purchase prices from at least three comparable properties. [5]
The income approach: This method is relevant for investment properties and is based on expected rental income, often over a period of 10 years.
The cost approach: It determines the value based on the construction costs of the building and the land value, minus depreciation due to age; relevant when no comparable properties exist. [5]
A qualified expert selects the appropriate method or a combination thereof to produce a market-consistent and comprehensible expert opinion. [3] The correct application of these methods is crucial for the preparation of the report and its acceptance.
Recognise the need for expert opinion in various life situations
In many situations, an expert opinion is not only advisable but often essential to avoid financial disadvantages or legal conflicts. When buying or selling property, an appraisal provides both parties with assurance about the fair market value and can improve the negotiation basis by up to 15%. [1] Particularly in the case of inheritances or divorces, an objective valuation ensures clarity and fairness in asset distribution; here, a court-proof appraisal by a publicly appointed expert is often required. [6] The tax office may also set an overly high value when assessing inheritance or gift tax; a counter-opinion can save a significant amount of money, as allowances, such as 400,000 Euros for children, are quickly exceeded. [6] In the event of damage to a property, an expert will document and evaluate this professionally, which can be crucial for insurance claims or legal disputes. [1] A challenge with property appraisals is often the complexity that requires expert insight.
Choose the right expert for your professional opinion
As the designation “Sachverständiger” or “Gutachter” is not comprehensively protected in Germany, selecting a qualified expert for a reliable expert opinion is of great importance. [1] There are different types of experts with varying qualifications:
Independent experts: They should be able to independently demonstrate their qualifications. Their assessments often do not carry the same weight in court. [1]
Certified experts: These individuals have demonstrated their expertise, for example, according to DIN EN ISO/IEC 17024. Such certifications are awarded by bodies like DEKRA or TÜV and signal verified expertise. [1]
Publicly appointed and sworn (ö.b.u.v.) experts: They are appointed by chambers (e.g., IHK) after rigorous examination, and their assessments are given special trust in court and by authorities. Their appointment is usually limited to 5 years. [1,7]
State-recognised experts: These are often employed by technical inspection organisations.
Look for demonstrable qualifications, at least 5-10 years of professional experience, and references. A reputable expert will transparently present their competencies and provide you with a clear offer. [7] For an initial assessment or in less complex cases, the ImmoGPT-Chat by Auctoa can offer helpful guidance before you engage an independent expert.
Weighing the costs and benefits of an expert opinion
The costs for an expert opinion in the form of a property valuation report have been freely negotiable since 2009 and are no longer rigidly regulated by the Fee Structure for Architects and Engineers (HOAI). [1] Prices vary depending on the type and scope of the report, the complexity of the property, and the qualification of the expert. A short report can cost between 500 and 1,500 euros, while a comprehensive market value report, often required for legal disputes, can cost up to 1.5% of the property's value or start from a flat rate of 1,500 euros upwards. [1,5] For example, the costs for a market value report on a property valued at 200,000 euros can range between 860 and 1,051 euros (normal level). [6] Although these costs may initially seem like an additional expense, the benefits are often much higher. A well-founded expert assessment can prevent poor decisions leading to financial losses amounting to tens of thousands of euros. [1] Therefore, investing in a professional valuation is worthwhile in most cases, as it provides negotiating confidence and protects against inflated prices or sales below value.
Understanding the process and content of a qualified property appraisal
The creation of a well-founded expert opinion follows a structured process to ensure the highest accuracy and traceability. Initially, the expert examines the commission and the completeness of the necessary documents, such as the land registry extract, building plans, and energy certificate. [5] A crucial step is the site visit, where the property is inspected in detail – this can take several hours. [5] The collected information and data are then fed into the analysis, where the appropriate valuation method (comparative, income, or cost method) is applied. A qualified report typically includes the following elements:
General information (address, report number)
Purpose of the report (e.g. purchase, inheritance)
Description of location and property
Documentation of the building condition and features
Applied valuation methodology and detailed calculations
Derivation of the market value
Summary and formal details (stamp, date) [1]
The duration for preparing a report averages 1 to 3 weeks. [5] Thorough quality assurance of the report is essential in this process.
sachverstandige-meinung
Digitalisation is also influencing property valuation. Online valuation tools, based on algorithms and extensive databases, can provide a quick, often free, initial orientation about the potential value of a property. [2] Such tools are useful for an initial assessment, especially for standard properties. However, they cannot fully replace a detailed expert opinion from a qualified professional, as they often inadequately consider the individual characteristics of the property, its exact condition, or specific legal circumstances. [2] Nonetheless, digital offerings like the ImmoGPT chat from Auctoa can be a valuable first point of contact to clarify basic questions and better assess the need for a comprehensive survey. The combination of technological tools and the expertise of a certified surveyor often leads to the best result: a quick initial assessment complemented by a thorough, individual analysis. This way, you can receive data-driven recommendations instead of relying solely on your intuition, which is a need for over 70% of property owners.
Conclusion: With informed opinions for well-founded property decisions
What is the difference between an expert opinion and an online review?
An online review provides an initial, often free estimate based on general data. An expert opinion is a detailed, individual report from a qualified expert, which also takes into account specific property features and legal aspects, and often holds up in court. [2]
How long is an expert opinion valid?
A property valuation report is generally valid for about six to twelve months, as market conditions and the condition of the property can change. [5]
What methods are used for an expert opinion?
The most common methods are the comparative value method, income value method, and cost value method, as regulated in the Property Valuation Ordinance (ImmoWertV). [2,5]
Can I deduct the costs of an expert opinion from my taxes?
Under certain conditions, such as if the report is related to the generation of income (e.g., renting, selling), the costs can be claimed for tax purposes. [5]
What is the market value according to § 194 of the Building Code?
The market value (fair value) is the price that could be achieved in normal business transactions according to the legal conditions, actual properties, and location of the plot, without regard to unusual or personal circumstances. [4]
How do I find a qualified expert?
Look for certifications (e.g., DIN EN ISO/IEC 17024), public appointments (IHK), memberships in professional associations, verifiable experience, and references. Auctoa can assist you with this, or you can get initial guidance with the ImmoGPT chat.
Additional useful links
The Federal Statistical Office (Destatis) offers a comprehensive overview of construction prices and the real estate price index in Germany.
Detailed tables on house and land prices are provided by the Federal Statistical Office (Destatis).
Current press releases on price developments can be found at the Federal Statistical Office (Destatis).
Methodological explanations and information on the revision of the House Price Index (HPI) are made available by the Federal Statistical Office (Destatis).
Statista offers statistical data on the House Price Index in Germany since the year 2000.
The ifo Institute publishes the ifo Real Estate Index, which reflects the current sentiment and development in the real estate market.
FAQ
What is the difference between an expert opinion and an online review?
An online appraisal provides an initial, often free estimate based on general data. An expert opinion is a detailed, individual report from a qualified professional that also takes specific property features and legal aspects into account, and often holds up in court. [2]
How long is an expert opinion valid?
A property valuation report is generally valid for approximately six to twelve months, as market conditions and the condition of the property can change. [5]
What methods are used for an expert opinion?
The most common methods are the comparative value, income value, and intrinsic value methods, which are regulated by the Immobilienwertermittlungsverordnung (ImmoWertV). [2,5]
Can I deduct the costs for an expert opinion on my taxes?
Under certain conditions, such as when the appraisal is related to the generation of income (e.g., rental, sale), the costs can be claimed for tax purposes. [5]
What is the market value according to § 194 BauGB?
The market value is the price that could be achieved in normal business transactions, based on the legal circumstances, actual characteristics, and location of the property, without regard to unusual or personal conditions. [4]
How do I find a qualified expert?
Pay attention to certifications (e.g. DIN EN ISO/IEC 17024), public appointments (IHK), memberships in professional associations, verifiable experience, and references. Auctoa can support you in this or provide an initial orientation with the ImmoGPT chat.
