An inherited house – unexpected blessing or financial burden? The decision between selling and renting has far-reaching financial consequences. We show you how to find the optimal strategy for your property inheritance using a calculator and the right data.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
The decision between selling and renting an inherited house largely depends on your financial situation, the condition of the property, and the tax framework.
A calculator can provide an initial orientation by comparing the one-time sales proceeds with the long-term rental income, minus all costs (maintenance, administration, taxes).
Tax aspects such as inheritance tax (allowances of €400,000 for children) and capital gains tax (10-year period) are crucial for the financial attractiveness of both options.
Inheriting a property immediately raises a central question: sell and secure quick capital or rent and generate long-term income? There's no one-size-fits-all answer. The right decision depends on your personal life situation, financial goals, and the condition and location of the house. Factors such as inheritance tax, potential capital gains tax, and ongoing costs must be carefully calculated. This article serves as your strategic compass and provides a data-driven analysis of both options. We guide you through the relevant calculations and show you how an inherited house selling or renting calculator can serve as a first tool to provide clarity.
The basics: What is your inherited property really worth?
Before you consider selling or renting, you need a solid data foundation: the current market value of the house. This value is the basis for any further calculation, whether it’s the potential sale proceeds or the rental yield. A professional property valuation provides you with a realistic market value, which is crucial for setting the sale price. It also serves as a basis for the tax office to calculate any potential inheritance tax. Even a 10% deviation in value can significantly impact your financial calculations. For an initial orientation, online tools can be helpful, but for a binding decision that could involve thousands of euros, a precise, AI-supported analysis like that from Auctoa is indispensable. The value of your inherited house determines the starting point of your entire strategy. With a clear valuation, you can objectively assess the financial implications of a sale.
Analysis of Sales: Quick Liquidity and Its Costs
Selling an inherited house promises a quick and significant one-time income. However, various costs must be deducted from the notarised sale price. In Germany, the buyer and seller usually share the estate agent's commission, often amounting to 3.57% of the sale price for each party. Additional costs include notary fees of about 1.5% and fees for discharging old mortgages. A frequently overlooked factor is the speculative tax. This applies if less than ten years have passed between the original purchase by the decedent and your sale. The decedent's period of ownership is transferred to you. An exception exists if the property was used personally in the year of sale and the two preceding years. The sum of these sales costs can quickly amount to 5–10% of the proceeds. A detailed list of pros and cons helps in making a decision:
Advantages: Quick liquidity, no administration tasks, clear division among co-heirs.
Disadvantages: One-time profit, transaction costs, potential tax burden.
A sale is often the simplest solution, especially for heirs in a co-ownership. However, the alternative of renting promises steady income and should therefore be carefully considered.
Rental Analysis: Long-Term Returns and Management Effort
Renting out your inherited house can provide a stable source of passive income. The annual net rental yield, which is the profit after deducting all expenses, often ranges between 2% and 4% in Germany. However, to achieve this yield, you must consider the ongoing costs and responsibilities of being a landlord. These include maintenance costs, for which experts recommend setting aside about 1% of the property's value annually. Additionally, there are costs for property management if you do not handle this yourself, and the risk of rental defaults, which can statistically amount to 3–5% of the annual rent. As a landlord, you are also legally required to prepare an annual service charge statement and ensure safety standards are met. Many underestimate the time commitment involved in tenant communication and maintenance. Before deciding to rent, you should consider the following steps:
Determine the local comparative rent.
Calculate all ongoing expenses (maintenance, management, insurance).
Estimate the expected post-tax rental yield.
Assess your own time availability for management.
Renting out is a business activity that requires careful calculation to avoid turning into a loss-making venture.
The direct comparison: A calculator for sale or rental
To answer the question "Sell or rent an inherited house?", a calculator helps to directly compare the two scenarios. Such a calculator simulates financial development over a specific period, often 10 to 15 years. It compares the net proceeds from an immediate sale with the cumulative rental income, minus all costs and taxes. Let's take an example: A house worth €400,000 could yield net proceeds of €368,000 after deducting sales costs (approximately 8%). Alternatively, it could be rented out for €1,400 per month, resulting in annual income of €16,800. After deducting maintenance (€4,000), management (€500), and taxes (approximately 30% on the surplus), you might be left with €8,610 per year. A calculator shows it could take over 42 years for rental income to match the sale proceeds. Such online tools are an excellent first step. However, for a precise decision, you should conduct a detailed analysis or use tools like the Auctoa ImmoGPT chat to check your specific figures. The Inheritance Comparison Calculator is only as good as the data you enter. However, the purely financial consideration is only one side of the coin.
Tax Pitfalls: Optimising Inheritance and Capital Gains Tax
Regardless of whether you are selling or renting, the tax office confronts you with two potential types of tax: inheritance tax and speculation tax. Inheritance tax depends on the value of the property and your degree of relationship. Children have an allowance of €400,000, spouses €500,000. If the value of the property is below this, no inheritance tax is due. For any amount exceeding this, tax rates between 7% and 30% apply. The speculation tax is levied on the sale profit if the ten-year period is not adhered to. The use of the property by the deceased or yourself can be crucial in avoiding the tax here. A rented property benefits from a 10% valuation discount on inheritance tax, which can reduce the tax burden. It is vital to carefully assess your own situation and, if necessary, use an inheritance tax calculator. These tax aspects can significantly alter the attractiveness of selling or renting and must be included in any decision.
Special cases: Need for renovation and the complexity of inheritance communities
Not every inherited house is in perfect condition. A house in need of renovation requires a significant initial investment before it can be rented out or sold at a profit. Energy-efficient renovations can quickly cost €50,000 or more, which diminishes the return or consumes the sale proceeds. Additional complexity arises if you are not the sole heir but part of an heir community. In an heir community, all decisions must be unanimous. Often, the co-heirs have different financial goals or emotional attachments to the property. Statistically, over 60% of heir communities end with a sale, as this is the simplest method to divide the assets. The alternative would be for one heir to buy out the others, which often represents a significant financial burden. A clear decision-making guide for heir communities is therefore essential to avoid conflicts. These special circumstances often tip the balance in favour of a quick and clean sale.
geerbtes-haus-verkaufen-oder-vermieten-rechner
The decision to sell or rent an inherited house is one of the most important financial crossroads you will face as an heir. There is no universally correct answer. Selling provides immediate liquidity and frees you from administrative burdens, while renting offers a long-term income source but is associated with costs and responsibility. Use an inherited house sale or rent calculator for an initial analysis, but rely on a professional appraisal and a careful consideration of all factors for the final decision: your financial goals, risk tolerance, and personal circumstances. A data-driven analysis transforms an inherited house from a complex duty into a clear opportunity.
Additional useful links
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) provides an overview of construction prices and the property price index in Germany.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) includes tables on house prices and land prices.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) provides a press release from the year 2025.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) offers another press release from the year 2025.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) published a press release from the year 2024.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis) explains the methods and revisions of the house price index (HPI).
Wikipedia offers a comprehensive article on inheritance law in Germany.
The Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (BGB) contains paragraph 1931 on the statutory succession rights of the spouse.
FAQ
How does a calculator help me decide between selling and renting?
A calculator for comparing selling versus renting is a valuable tool for initial guidance. It quantifies both options by comparing the one-time net proceeds from the sale (after deducting costs like agent fees and notary charges) against the net rental income accumulated over the years (after deducting maintenance, management, and taxes). This way, you can see which scenario might be financially more advantageous in the short and long term.
What should I consider in a community of heirs?
In an inheritance community, all decisions must be made unanimously. This often leads to complications, as co-heirs may have differing interests. Selling the property is often the most pragmatic solution, as the proceeds can be easily divided among the heirs. Renting requires long-term joint management, which is prone to conflict.
What role does the condition of the inherited house play?
The condition is crucial. A house in need of renovation requires high initial investments before it can be rented out, significantly reducing the return. When selling, a poor condition can heavily depress the price. It must be weighed whether a renovation before the sale is worthwhile to achieve a higher return.
Can I try renting and still sell later on?
Yes, this is a common strategy. You can initially rent out the property to generate ongoing income and benefit from potential increases in value. However, be aware that when selling later, the 10-year speculation period applies from the original purchase date of the testator. Renting out does not interrupt the current period.
What ongoing responsibilities do I have as a landlord?
As a landlord, you are responsible for the maintenance of the property and need to set aside provisions for this. You must prepare an annual service charge statement, ensure safety obligations (e.g. winter maintenance) are met, and attend to your tenants' concerns. This administrative workload should not be underestimated.
How can Auctoa help me with the decision?
Auctoa provides an accurate, AI-powered real estate assessment, giving you a reliable foundation for your calculations. Additionally, you can use our interactive ImmoGPT chat to clarify specific questions about your situation and better understand the financial implications of selling or renting. This way, you can make an informed decision based on data, rather than relying on intuition.
