Are you considering leasing or letting a piece of land but are uncertain about the legal pitfalls and optimal contract design? This article sheds light on the most important aspects, from profit yield to duration, so your decision is based on a solid foundation. Learn how to avoid common mistakes and safeguard your interests.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
The main difference between lease and rent is the lessee's right to draw benefits, that is, to generate economic returns from the property.
A written lease agreement is essential and should clearly stipulate details concerning rent, duration, usage, maintenance, and termination.
The leasehold allows construction on someone else's land for an annual ground rent, but it carries specific risks and requires careful contract review.
Leasing a plot of land – is it a sensible alternative to buying or renting? Many private property owners and heirs face this question when it comes to the use or exploitation of land. Unlike renting, leasing grants the right to harvest the fruits, i.e., to economically utilise the property, for example, for agriculture or building a home under hereditary building rights. This article guides you through the key points you need to consider when leasing a plot of land, from contract details to long-term implications. This way, you can make an informed decision and secure your investment.
Pacht vs. Miete: Understanding the Key Difference
The main difference between lease and rent lies in the right to yield proceeds. While a tenant is only allowed to use a property, for example for relaxation, they are not permitted to develop it or generate economic returns from it. However, a lessee is allowed to manage the property and claim resulting profits, such as fruit harvests or rental income from a building erected thereon, for themselves. This distinction is fundamental, as it significantly influences the possibilities of use and contractual agreements. For many ventures, such as agriculture or running a business, a lease agreement is therefore indispensable. The distinction between rent and lease is thus the first important step.
The decision on whether leasing is the right choice strongly depends on your individual goals and how you plan to use the property. A thorough analysis of your needs can provide clarity here. For an initial assessment of whether leasing your property is worthwhile, an AI-backed property valuation can offer valuable insights.
The Lease Agreement: These Key Points You Must Address
A lease agreement should always be in writing to provide legal clarity for both parties. Although verbal agreements are theoretically possible, they carry significant risks. The essential components of a lease agreement include the precise description of the leased asset, the agreed duration, and the amount of rent. The rent can be set as a fixed sum or as a percentage of revenue. It is advisable to also detail provisions regarding operating costs, maintenance obligations, and proper management. In the case of land leases lasting more than two years that are not fixed in writing, they are considered concluded for an indefinite period according to §585a BGB. Careful drafting of the lease agreement protects against future disagreements.
The following points should not be missing from any lease agreement:
Exact description of the leased property (location, size, boundaries).
Start and duration of the lease relationship (fixed-term/indefinite).
Amount and payment terms of the rent.
Usage regulations (e.g., type of management, building possibilities).
Obligations for maintenance and cost responsibility for repairs.
Agreements on notice periods and reasons for termination.
Provisions on pre-emption rights or subleasing, if applicable.
The complexity of lease agreements often requires careful examination. The ImmoGPT chat from Auctoa can answer initial questions about specific contract clauses and help you identify critical points.
Term and Termination: Ensure Long-term Planning Security
Lease agreements can be concluded for a fixed term or an indefinite period. Fixed-term contracts end automatically after the agreed period, usually requiring no notice. Indefinite contracts, on the other hand, require proper termination, with notice periods varying depending on the type of lease. For a standard land lease agreement, the notice period according to § 584 BGB is six months at the end of the lease year. For agricultural leases, a longer notice period of two years often applies. Special termination rights may exist for the heirs in the event of the tenant's death. A long-term lease requires careful consideration.
It is important to know that the principle "purchase does not break lease" applies. This means that the sale of the property by the lessor does not usually terminate the lease agreement; the new owner enters into the existing contract. Exceptions may exist if the new owner wishes to use the property themselves. An early termination of the contract is often only possible through a lease termination agreement by mutual consent or due to valid reasons such as the tenant's default on payment. These regulations provide a certain level of security but also necessitate a thorough examination of the legal framework.
Leasehold: Consider the option of building on someone else's land
Leasehold, colloquially often referred to as heritable building right, is a special form of lease. It allows the leaseholder to construct or own a building on someone else's land, while the land itself remains the property of the grantor of the heritable building right. In return, the leaseholder pays an annual ground rent, which is usually based on the land value and typically ranges between 3% and 5%. Contracts often have very long durations, frequently 99 years. This can be particularly attractive for builders with less capital, as the high costs of land purchase are avoided. However, a careful consideration of the risks and opportunities of the heritable building right is essential.
Important aspects of the heritable building right are:
Ground rent: It can increase during the term, often adjustable every three years.
Contract term: Usually 50 to 99 years; what happens at the end of the term?
Reversion: Under what circumstances does the right revert early to the landowner?
Compensation: At the end of the contract or reversion, the leaseholder usually receives only two-thirds of the market value of the building.
Landowner's right of say: In the case of sale, conversion, or refinancing of the property.
Costs: The leaseholder bears the costs of property acquisition tax, land tax, and development costs.
Before deciding on a leasehold plot, you should carefully review the contract details and calculate the long-term financial commitments. An independent assessment of the land and conditions by Auctoa can help you avoid hidden financial traps.
Costs and Economic Efficiency: Calculating the Lease Correctly
The amount of rent is a central issue and can be set freely but reasonably by the lessor. There is no general formula for calculation. In addition to the pure lease, operating costs for waste disposal, street cleaning or property tax can also be passed on to the lessee. For leasing land for solar systems, rental income of €3,000 to €5,000 per hectare per year can be achieved, for example. For agricultural land, lease prices often vary significantly by region. The costs of purchase or lease should be carefully compared.
For lessors, it is important to determine the market-based rent price in order to achieve a fair return. Lessees, on the other hand, must ensure that the rent and additional costs do not jeopardise the profitability of their project. A data-driven valuation, such as that offered by Auctoa, can provide both parties with a solid basis for price negotiations and helps realistically assess long-term profitability. This is particularly relevant when it comes to leasing recreational properties or land for tiny houses.
Consider special lease forms and usage possibilities
Aside from the classic land lease or hereditary building right, there are various other usage scenarios for leased land. Leasing a lake, for example, could come with the permission for fishing. Forest land is often leased together with hunting rights. It is also common to lease properties with inventory, such as fully equipped restaurants. In such cases, the lessee is responsible for the maintenance of the inventory. For allotments, there are often specific legal requirements, such as indefinite contracts and capped lease amounts.
The specific use must be precisely defined in the lease agreement. This prevents misunderstandings later about what is and isn’t allowed on the property. An unclear definition of use can lead to significant problems, especially if investments have been made on the property. Therefore, clarify in advance the exact rights and obligations associated with the particular form of lease. This is particularly true for niche uses, where standard contracts are often insufficient.
grundstuck-pachten-was-zu-beachten-ist
The tenant is generally obliged to manage the leased property properly. This means they must not exploit the land and must ensure its preservation. This also includes the maintenance of any included inventory. The landlord must provide the tenant with the land in a condition suitable for contractual use and maintain it in this condition during the leasing period, unless otherwise agreed. A clear division of responsibilities, especially regarding repairs and maintenance, should be recorded in the lease agreement. This prevents later disputes over cost-sharing and responsibilities.
Important obligations of the tenant include:
Payment of the agreed rent.
Proper management and usage according to the contract.
Maintenance of the leased property to the agreed extent.
Tolerance of necessary maintenance measures by the landlord.
Return of the leased property in a condition as specified by the contract at the end of the lease.
The landlord is obliged to grant the tenant use and enjoyment of the property. They must also ensure that the land is free of third-party rights that could restrict use, unless these are known to the tenant and considered in the contract.
Conclusion: Leasing land – making a decision with foresight
What should I particularly consider when leasing land for house construction (heritable building right)?
Pay special attention to the duration of the heritable building right contract (often 99 years), the amount and adaptability of the ground rent, provisions for reversion (premature return), the amount of compensation at the end of the contract, the property owner's rights to have a say, and who bears costs such as land transfer tax and development costs.
What costs arise when leasing a plot of land?
In addition to the rent, operating costs (waste, street cleaning), property tax, costs for maintenance and repairs, and possibly development costs (during construction) may arise. In the case of a heritable building right, land transfer tax is also incurred.
Can I sublease a leased plot of land?
Subleasing is generally only permissible with the express permission of the lessor. Unauthorized subleasing can be grounds for immediate termination without notice.
What does "usufruct" mean in lease law?
Usufruct refers to the tenant's right to derive economic benefits from the leased property. These can be agricultural products (fruit, vegetables) or rental income from a building located on the leased plot.
Do I need a notary for a lease agreement?
A simple lease agreement does not necessarily require notarisation. However, if a right of first refusal is agreed upon in connection with a lease for house construction, or if it concerns a heritable building rights contract, notarisation is required.
What happens if the lessor sells the land?
In principle, "purchase does not break lease". The lease contract remains in effect, and the new owner assumes the contract. Exceptions can be contractually agreed upon or if the new owner wishes to use the land themselves and adheres to certain deadlines.
Additional useful links
Das Bundesministerium der Justiz provides the Federal Allotment Garden Act (BKleingG), which governs the legal basis for allotment gardens in Germany.
Das Serviceportal Rheinland-Pfalz offers information on various services, including topics related to land and real estate.
Das Statistische Bundesamt (Destatis) explains leasehold rights in the context of topics such as work and earnings.
Die Bundesverwaltung provides an overview of services in building and housing in its service directory.
Der Deutsche Verband für Wohnungswesen, Städtebau und Raumordnung e.V. provides documentation of the expert dialogue on leasehold rights.
Der Deutsche Bundestag offers a document dealing with aspects of leasehold rights or related legislation.
Das Forum Baulandmanagement NRW provides a work aid on leasehold rights.
Wikipedia offers a comprehensive overview of the lease agreement in Germany.
Das Bundesministerium der Justiz provides Section 581 of the Civil Code (BGB), which regulates the general provisions of the lease agreement.
FAQ
What do I need to particularly consider when leasing land for house construction (hereditary building right)?
Pay special attention to the term of the leasehold contract (often 99 years), the amount and adjustability of the ground rent, provisions for reversion (early return), the amount of compensation at the end of the contract, the landowner's rights to be involved in decisions, and who bears costs such as land transfer tax and development charges.
What costs are involved in leasing a plot of land?
In addition to the lease rent, there may be operating costs (such as waste disposal, street cleaning), property tax, maintenance and repair costs, as well as any development costs (during construction). For hereditary building rights, the real estate transfer tax is added.
Can I sublease a leased plot of land?
A sublease is generally only permitted with the explicit permission of the lessor. An unauthorised sublease may be grounds for immediate termination.
What does "Fruchtziehung" mean in leasehold law?
Fruchtziehung means the tenant's right to derive economic benefits from the leased object. This can include agricultural products (fruit, vegetables) as well as rental income from a building located on the leased property.
Do I need a notary for a lease agreement?
A simple lease agreement does not necessarily require notarisation. However, if a right of first refusal in connection with a lease for a house construction is agreed or if it is a hereditary building right contract, notarisation is required.
What happens if the lessor sells the property?
As a rule, 'purchase does not break lease'. The lease agreement remains in force, and the new owner enters into the contract. Exceptions can be contractually agreed upon, or if the new owner wishes to use the property themselves and adheres to certain deadlines.
