Are you facing a sale, an inheritance, or simply want to know the current market value of your property? A well-informed valuation is key to making the right decisions and avoiding costly mistakes. Learn how to accurately determine the value of your property.
Chat with ImmoGPT for free now.
With access to Google, BORIS, and Deep Research.
The topic briefly and concisely
A professional valuation takes into account individual property characteristics and current market data for an accurate assessment.
The ImmoWertV 2021 ensures uniform and transparent standards in property valuation across the country.
Online valuation tools offer an initial orientation but do not replace a detailed expert analysis, especially in the case of complex issues or legal matters.
An accurate valuation of your property is often the first step towards making important financial decisions. Whether for a sale, inheritance settlement, or wealth overview – the correct value is crucial. This article guides you through the recognised valuation methods, highlights the role of digital tools such as AI-based analysis, and explains the effects of the current ImmoWertV. You will receive practical tips to avoid pitfalls and create a reliable valuation basis. With this knowledge, you maximise your results and make data-driven decisions.
Fundamentals of Valuation: Focus on Three Recognised Methods
The Immobilienwertermittlungsverordnung (ImmoWertV) governs the principles of real estate value assessment in Germany. Three main methods are legally recognized for value estimation. The comparison method analyzes sale prices of similar properties in comparable locations and is often used for owner-occupied houses and condominiums. It frequently provides very realistic market values, as it is based on actual sale prices. For an accurate valuation of your property, the quality of the data is crucial. This method requires a sufficient number of comparable properties, ideally more than 10, to deliver statistically valid results. The accuracy heavily depends on the comparability of the properties, with deviations of over 30% in individual characteristics potentially being critical. The other two methods offer alternative approaches for more specific types of properties.
Income and asset value methods: When are they applied?
The income method is central to the valuation of income-producing properties such as apartment buildings or commercial properties. It is based on the expected future rental income, with the land value and the building income value considered separately. The property yield rate, which reflects the market rate of return for comparable properties, plays a key role here; it often ranges between 3% and 7%. The cost approach, on the other hand, determines the value from the cost of new construction of the building, minus depreciation, plus the land value. This method is often used for owner-occupied properties for which there are few comparables, such as highly individual architect-designed houses or special-purpose properties. An appraiser often combines at least two methods for a well-founded valuation. Choosing the right method is an important first step in any valuation.
Digital assistants: Opportunities and limitations of online reviews and AI
Free online property valuations provide an initial, quick orientation and can deliver a rough price range within a few minutes. Many of these tools use algorithms based on offer databases, such as those from major real estate portals. But beware: offer prices are not the same as selling prices; the difference can be up to 20%. Additionally, these automated systems often do not account for individual features like a recent high-quality renovation or specific defects. For precise valuations with tools, often more is needed. Artificial intelligence (AI) takes a step further. AI-powered systems can analyze massive amounts of data, including unstructured data like images or text descriptions, and recognize patterns that human analysts may miss. They promise to speed up and objectify the valuation process but do not replace the expertise of an experienced appraiser, especially with complex properties. The future of valuation likely lies in a hybrid approach that combines the best of both worlds.
The Role of the Expert: Added Value through Expertise and Local Knowledge
A qualified real estate appraiser brings crucial advantages for property valuation. They conduct a detailed property inspection and take into account individual features that online tools often overlook – from structural damage to high-quality renovations. A professional appraisal is often a prerequisite for bank financing, which plays a role in over 80% of property purchases. In addition, it is typically indispensable and legally sound for legal matters such as divorce or inheritance. The appraiser is familiar with local market conditions and relies on informed data, for example from valuation methodology experts and appraisal committees. The cost of a full appraisal can range from 0.5% to 1.5% of the property value, depending on the value and effort involved, but provides a reliable basis for important decisions. The following documents are typically required for an appraisal:
Current land registry excerpt (not older than 3 months)
Location plan/cadastral map
Building plans (floor plans, sections, elevations)
Living space calculation
Energy certificate
Proof of renovations from the last 15 years
For condominiums: Declaration of division, minutes of the last 3 owners' meetings
For rented properties: Tenancy agreements and current rental statements
These documents enable a comprehensive and accurate valuation.
Valuation in the event of inheritance: Special requirements of the tax office
In the event of inheritance, a correct valuation of the property is essential for determining inheritance tax. The tax office usually assesses the value based on statutory valuation procedures according to the Valuation Act (BewG). Since the 2009 reform, the market value (fair value) has been decisive. A potentially overestimated value by the tax office can lead to an unnecessarily high tax burden. Heirs have the right to prove a lower market value through a qualified expert opinion. This can often reduce the tax burden by several thousand euros. If the property is sold within a year of inheritance at a lower price, this selling price can serve as proof. For rented residential properties, the tax authorities grant a 10% valuation discount under certain conditions. An early valuation initiation can save a significant amount of money. The complexity often requires expert advice.
Market data and situation analysis: The foundation of every solid value assessment
The location is one of the most important value drivers of a property, often quoted as 'Location, location, location'. The distinction is made between the macro location (region, city) and the micro location (immediate surroundings, street). For a comprehensive value assessment, current market data is essential. Sources for this include the reports from quality providers, price indices from associations such as the IVD, or data from specialised providers like Sprengnetter. These entities collect and analyse millions of transaction data points. Land values, determined at least every two years by local expert committees, indicate the average value of the land per square metre and are an important basis for the cost and comparative value methods. Current market reports for 2024/2025 show a stabilisation of property prices with slight regional increases, particularly for energy-efficient properties in good locations. A careful analysis of these factors is crucial for a realistic value assessment.
appreciation of value
The Immobilienwertermittlungsverordnung (ImmoWertV 2021), which came into effect on 1 January 2022, consolidates and standardises the previously distributed regulations on real estate valuation across several sets of rules. It replaced the ImmoWertV 2010 as well as various guidelines (e.g., the tangible asset and income value guidelines) and now combines their content authoritatively. The aim was to achieve a more transparent and nationwide consistent determination of market values. The new regulation is significantly more comprehensive than its predecessor, featuring 54 paragraphs and 5 annexes. Important aspects include, among others, more detailed requirements for data collection and usage as well as model conformity. For experts, this means a higher binding nature of certain calculation parameters, such as total usage durations, which are now partially fixed. The risk minimisation through standardised valuation is a core objective. The transition periods for the full application of all new regulations ended on 31 December 2024. This ensures that all value assessments from 2025 onwards are carried out according to the latest standards.
Practical Tips for Owners: How to Prepare an Optimal Valuation
What is the difference between market value and fair value?
In German valuation law, the terms market value and fair value are used synonymously. § 194 of the BauGB defines the fair value (market value) as the price that could be achieved in the ordinary course of business under the legal conditions and actual characteristics, the other condition and location of the property or other object of the valuation without regard to unusual or personal circumstances.
Why does the online value often differ from the actual sale price?
Online valuations are usually based on algorithms and databases with listing prices, not on actual sale prices. Individual property features (condition, facilities, renovations, defects) and the specific micro-location are often insufficiently considered, which can lead to deviations of 10-20%.
Is a valuation necessary for insurance purposes?
For taking out building insurance, the so-called 'value of 1914' or the new building value is usually required to avoid underinsurance. A current fair value assessment can provide a basis for this but is not always exactly the value that the insurer uses. It is advisable to coordinate this with the insurer.
How does the energy performance certificate influence the valuation?
The energy performance certificate provides information about the energy efficiency of a building. Good energy efficiency (e.g. classes A+, A, B) can increase the value of a property, as lower energy costs are expected. Properties with poor energy efficiency (e.g. G, H), on the other hand, may experience value deductions, as there is often a need for renovation. This aspect is becoming increasingly important.
Can I assess the value of my property myself?
You can make a rough initial assessment by comparing current property listings in your area and using online valuation tools. However, for an accurate and reliable valuation, especially for sales negotiations, financing, or legal purposes, the expertise of a qualified appraiser or real estate expert such as Auctoa is advisable.
What role do standard land values play in the valuation?
Standard land values are average values for land in certain zones determined by expert committees. They are an important basis in the cost value method (for determining land value) and can also serve as a guide in the comparative value method. However, the individual value of a property may differ from the standard land value due to specific characteristics.
Additional useful links
Wikipedia provides a comprehensive introduction to property valuation and its various methods.
The Council of Economic Experts publishes annual reports containing important economic analyses and forecasts relevant to the property market.
The National Association of German Cooperative Banks (BVR) offers detailed property market reports with current data and analyses on the development of the German property market.
The Federal Association of Publicly Appointed and Sworn as well as Qualified Experts (BSVI) provides information about the role and qualifications of experts essential for well-founded property valuations.
FAQ
What is the difference between market value and fair value?
In German assessment law, the terms market value and fair value are used synonymously. Section 194 of the Federal Building Code (BauGB) defines the fair value (market value) as the price that could be achieved under normal business transactions according to the legal conditions and actual characteristics, the other condition and the location of the property or other subject of the valuation, without consideration of unusual or personal circumstances.
Why does the online value often differ from the actual selling price?
Online reviews are usually based on algorithms and databases with offer prices, not on actual sale prices achieved. Individual property characteristics (condition, features, refurbishments, defects) and the specific micro-location can often only be insufficiently taken into account, which can lead to deviations of 10-20%.
Is a valuation necessary for insurance?
To take out building insurance, the so-called '1914 value' or the new building value is usually required to avoid underinsurance. A current market value assessment can provide a basis for this, but it is not always the exact value the insurer uses. It is advisable to coordinate this with the insurer.
How does the energy certificate influence the valuation?
The energy performance certificate provides information about a building's energy efficiency. Good energy efficiency (e.g., classes A+, A, B) can increase a property's value as lower energy costs are expected. Properties with poor energy ratings (e.g., G, H), on the other hand, may face value reductions as they often require renovations. This aspect is becoming increasingly important.
Can I assess the value of my property myself?
You can make a rough initial assessment yourself by comparing current property listings in your area and using online evaluation tools. However, for an accurate and reliable valuation, especially for sales negotiations, financing, or legal purposes, the expertise of a qualified appraiser or real estate expert like Auctoa is advisable.
What role do standard land values play in property valuation?
Standard land values are average values for land in specific zones determined by expert committees. They serve as an important basis in the real value method (for determining land value) and can also be used as a guideline in the comparative value method. However, the individual value of a property may differ from the standard land value due to specific characteristics.
